Customer Reviews Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

I bought the moss color. I thought I ordered the black but the greenish color came so I was like ?, but then first time I applied it, it was good. Better than the other liquid types. It's easy to use and it does smudge. It even dries fast. I like it.

Finally! I found an eyeliner that doesn't smudge. I have oily lids and tried both the MAC fluidline blacktrack and makeup forever aqua black waterproof cream eye liner. They both smudged and I hated wearing eyeliner because of it. STILA is the best. The pointy tip took a lil getting used to.. at first it tickled my skin.

This is great, stays on very well and I have oily eye lids. It\'s easy to apply. I will buy this again.

I have been using liquid eyeliner for years; I have used all the expensive department store brands and the drugstore brands as well, but by far Stila has the best liquid eyeliner hands down! It glides effortlessly, and stays on all day. Price is reasonable, too, not outrageously priced! Definitely a new Stila follower here! I’m sold!

This product is truly amazing and I love it....the tip is very soft and easy to use without being messy. If you are picky about your liquid liner, this is the perfect product to use.

I love it. I got the brown color and planning to get the black one. It's easy to apply and very precise. Love the Zappos.

This is the best liquid eye liner I ever purchased! It works great! It stays on all day and goes on smoothly! I love this brand!

I will never buy any other eyeliner. It is easy to apply and stays put until I wash it off. I love it.

This product is of excellent quality. The precision that you can apply a thin line or a heavier line is in the brush. You won't go back to your old liner.

This eye liner is awesome! I used to have the regular liquid liner and it was just so hard to apply. You get the exact same affect using the Stila liner but it's so much easier to use! Nice, easy to apply dark lines. Very thin line but you can make it as thick as you want. I know it sounds silly but I watched a "liquid liner tutorial" and that helped a lot.

This product is definitely true to its name! I was a loyal liquid eyeliner user, but after using this, I am never going back. It goes on smoothly and stays on beautifully. I very highly recommend this eye liner!

I am very picky about eye liners and I never write reviews, but had to for this one. It is sharp and when I put it on, it looks like it was done by a professional makeup artist.

I personally love this eyeliner! It stays on all day and it is so easy to create the perfect winged eye with this! It is also so convenient because you do not have to carry around an eyeliner brush.

Great liner. Easy to apply. I have allergies and my eyes water a lot. This stays on all day.

This is a great eyeliner! Waterproof and lasts all day long!

I tried this eyeliner after reading rave reviews. I bought one and loved it so much, I bought another one when I needed it. My only complaint is the eyeliner seemed to run out really fast. I can get one eye done and there isn't enough product to do the other eye at the time. It may be I just got a lemon, but for the price, I wanted it to last a little longer than it did.

This is the first liquid eye liner I have bought in years. Usually they are messy and I end up looking like a raccoon. This eye pen is precise delivering just the right amount of liquid without smudging. I love it and highly recommend it.

This is one of my favorite liquid eyeliners. Stays on all day, water-resistant, and smudge proof with eye primer (if you have oily eyelids like I do, I recommend investing in an eye primer). I do, however, have to reapply in the inner corner of my eyes (that's because I have teary eyes) and does not go crazy when my eyes tear up can easily fix.

This does not live up to its hype. I found it no better than any waterproof eye make up that can be purchased for considerably cheaper.

I am returning this eyeliner. I was convinced by the reviews that I would like it, but was very disappointed. The felt-like tip drags and the metallic look of the black is only appropriate for nightclubs. I tried giving the eyeliner away to my friends after one application, and nobody wanted it; even for free. I will stick to my Maybelline pencil.

Does not stay on at all! Won't even go on the bottom lid, and leaves a lot of residue in the eye. Waste of money.

I love this liquid eyeliner. I think this is the only one that I have tried that does not smear or rub off without needing to use in combination with other eye make up products like eye shadow, etc. and it lasts all day. I would say my lids are on the oily side and this will stay on from early in the morning until later in the evening. I mean, it will smudge if you were really working at rubbing your eyes... but come on, it is no Sharpie. It is definitely highly recommended! It is super easy to apply thanks to its pen tipped style, the tip stays sharp and firm enough for ease of application and control but soft enough where it does not feel like you are stabbing your eyelids, does not get leaky, and lasts a very long time even with daily use. Totally worth the price. The only downside, though, if you are applying it on top of a lot of eye shadow, it dries out faster. For those days, I use it as a base layer eyeliner and then use a dipping type over my eye shadow.

This is truly the perfect liquid eyeliner. I had loved the look of liquid liner, had tried lots of different brands but could never get it quite right because I always had difficulty applying it. I finally get the perfect lined eye with this Stila liner. Along with its ease of use it stays on all day without any flaking. My first liner lasted five months (with everyday use) and I'm currently on my second one.

The best waterproof eye liner I've ever used! Hot, humid, weather? No problem! Stila stays put all day long, no melting, raccoon eyes. Color goes on rich too. Buy it today. Do not delay!

This is the only eyeliner that I have bought over and over again. It is easy to apply, you can make it thin or thick, it looks great, and lasts all day. It is totally worth it.