Customer Reviews Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

This eyeliner is the felt pen type. As much as I love the control of the line and the precise detail that can be achieved I have never gotten the opacity that I desire from this type of application. I am also once again disappointed in the staying power of this product during the summer. One afternoon birthday party and the line is barely there.

Stila is one of my favorite makeup brands, so when I discovered Zappos carries their projects I was so excited! I'm a big fan of their liquid liners, and was over the moon when I saw Zappos has the turquoise shade, which is sold out everywhere else. Application and pigmentation are both great; I wore this with a primer and had no staining. Absolutely worth it!

This is my first time using this liner. I'm not sure why I bother trying others since the Loreal liner is the best! While this has an extra thin tip and goes on as smoothly, I will still go back to using Loreal.

This is my favorite eyeliner. It makes doing a cat eye extremely easy, and the grey color is nice instead of the intense black color. I'm a redhead, so black can be too dark.

I love this eyeliner! This is my second purchase of it from Zappos. I love the color, it goes on like a dream - and stays on...great stuff!

Before trying this eyeliner I always used Smashbox but usually by the end of the day it was flaking and smearing off. I have very oily eyelids so this is a constant problem for me but not with this one. I read in another review that the brown is different formula than the black and more prone to smear. I agree with this. I also prefer this over Smash box because it looks more matte where the other is kind if shiny.

Great liquid liner, especially for hard-to-line, aging eyes (it gets a lot harder when you're not twenty-something!). It has a super-fine, firm point and allows you to make finite adjustments to your line without ending up looking like a panda. The fact that it's waterproof is a major plus.

I bought this on a whim and it has quickly become my new favorite. It glides effortlessly leaving a perfectly smooth and even line across your eyelid. So easy to work with, fits in your hand just like your favorite pen. Depending on how thick/dark you want it it, multiple applications may be necessary. A must have in my beauty regiment.

I have spent most of my adult life looking for an eyeliner that would stay in place through a full 15 hour work day. This one will do it if paired with Too-Faced's Shadow Insurance (not sold on Zappos but should be. Check Amazon or Ulta Cosmetics). I can't say that about any of the literally dozens and dozens of other liquid liners/ smudge sticks/ pots of gunk I've tried over the years. This only one I ever buy now.

Has definite staying power! I love this eyeliner...glides on easy (felt tip), dries fast, and lasts me all day. Once it dries it takes some effort to fix any mistakes (a wet Q-tip and some rubbing), but it's not impossible. Corrections are easier when the liner is still wet.

I'm the one who bought the moss color last time. I ordered black this time. I definitely recommend this Stila eye liner. It dries fast and super easy to use.

This eyeliner really does stay on all day long...and the best part is that it doesn't leave crease marks on your eyelid! The only other one I've found that works this well is Estee Lauder Double wear, but I am allergic to MMA...so I had to find another. After many many drugstore returns, I have found this Stila eyeliner, and I'm hooked. The only downside is that there seems no way to get more to come out of the brush - you can't really 'press harder' or re-dip when you are applying because it is just a pen.

I love this liner! I've tried many liquid liners, department store & drugstore brands & this one by far is the best! It stays on all day & the tip is precise enough to draw a straight line. I use it to line the top of my eye.

This eyeliner served what it was designed for. I wanted a waterproof eyeliner that'll stay all day in a sunny and humid weather (i.e., Punta Cana) and water activities. This was a great choice! No smudging, no panda eyes, nothing. It lasted all day and it was easy to remove with an oil-based makeup remover. Definitely worth it.

Sorry I haven't been able to get a good line at the base of my lashes. I have tried drawing a straight, smooth one stroke line, used closely placed dots between individual lashes both with and without adding tension on the eyelids. I also tried different bases: bare skin, foundation on lids, and also tried it with just eye primer. I am skilled at makeup application. Once I was having a makeover, and I overheard one sales rep tell another rep "She looked better when she came in!" (Before the makeover.) I am saddened that my experience with this liner did not match the others rave reviews. Wish the product worked for me!

I didn't care for this liner. It is so fine you can't even see it.

Loved the ease of how well this went on, but I realized that, that is what was making my eyes water all day, not my allergies. I finally came to the conclusion I was allergic to it after I went back to my old brand. It was truly a great liquid eyeliner, just too bad I couldn't wear it. Normally I am not that sensitive, so I'm not sure why this happened. Will need to return.

The product was great. Prices and customer service was excellent. However, the shipping method was horrible. First time I ordered, the product came packed in a huge larger than shoe box carton with lots of paper inside. Really? I don't think Zapped considers the environment at all. I would think they would save much more by packing Un a small bubble lined envelope. I wrote to them the first time explaining all this. So the second time I gave them a try again. The same thing. The eyeliner came in a huge box once again. Not sure I'd order from here again. I'm not the type to write bad reviews but big companies like Zappos who are not environmentally conscious need to get zapped! Would've given them 5 as stars but not until they make some changes in the shipping department.

Don't bother. Not waterproof! 5 minutes after I put it on it was half gone. Sending it back.

Terrible product, does not do what it claims at all. It smears, runs and is not waterproof. I look like a smudged mess in less than 3 hours. Lousy product, builds up in the corners of the eyes and then runs. Does not do what it claims, not even close.