Customer Reviews Klogs Footwear Carolina

I wanted these to work! They are SO comfortable but there is a trim at the toes that is very hard and feels very uncomfortable.

Love these shoes, style is so cute, and the arch support is a perfect fit for my high arches! However the straps were just a little too tight. High arches make me need a shoe with more room across the top. There is some give to them, and I'm sure they would stretch some with wear, but they put too much painful pressure on the top of my foot for me to wait that out. As a nurse, I need them to be comfortable from the get go. Exchanging for a different style I have had before that worked well.

I have these in a wide width, but felt I needed to wear socks to help them fit well. I tried regular width which is still wide, but still not as comfortable as my other three pairs of Klogs. I am returning them.

These definitely run big. I am a size 9.5-10 and C-width and I tried the 9.5 in medium (which, for these, are a C-width, see the drop-down menu next to the shoe-pics) and the 9.5 was too long. Size 9 would have been perfect. The width was adequate. The only problem I had was the cross straps were too loose (but maybe would not have been in the 9's, but I decided not to try these in anymore sizes...because...) and they felt too heavy for me. Otherwise, these are quality clogs and I highly recommend them to anyone who struggles to find wide enough shoes and who doesn't mind a sorta "weighty" clog. Obviously, if you are a bigger (taller) person with smaller feet, they won't feel as heavy for you.

I am a long standing Dansko girl and now have to get used to the idea of wearing orthotics. These shoes say they can take orthotics, which Danskos do not. I was hoping I would feel able to get away wearing with these with dresses (professional style health dresses, etc.) but the style is just a little too funky for that, I think. Nevertheless, they are very comfortable. They feel like a cross between Danskos and Earth shoes in their overall look on the foot.

Cute shoes, but! I have a pair of Klogs Naples that I absolutely love. I've worn them to death. They fit my wide feet perfectly, so I had high hopes for the Carolina. They are really cute, and the width is perfect, but where the strap crosses, there's a painful pressure point. Such a bummer! I really wanted them to work out. Sorry to have to return them.

I found these true to size for a 7M - C width, not B. Insole is much better than most. Unfortunately, as I suspected, they were too high for me, putting pressure on my instep and arthritic knees. I have very high arches and removed the insoles for orthotics.

Very cute, but too large. Usually wear an 8.5 and had to order a 7.5. Very comfortable foot bed.

In the past have gotten Klogs in 8.5W but they been too big. So I went for an 8M for my usual 8.5W feet and the fit is good. There is moderate arch support and nice interior which keeps my flat-footed toes from splaying to the side...nice style, good heel, great color (jeans-blue). HOWEVER, the straps on the left shoe were quite stretched out, making the shoe loose. I'm going to try to get a replacement, assuming the someone wore the left shoe and damaged it...unless the straps in this size/color are defective?

Beautiful shoe but it was too wide for my foot and I wear a wide!

My first pair of Klogs and was very impressed. I found them to run 1/2 size larger and a bit wider (I purchased the wide width) than expected. Was grateful to other Zappos customers for the heads up on sizing and ordered 1/2 size smaller and they fit perfectly! Overall great support in the footbed. Would have liked more a supportive structure with the shoe (feet seem to feel slightly squishy and not held is as snugly as I would have liked.) I wear Dansko's often and appreciate their very structured/solid feel. Perhaps I'll adjust with more wear. Definitely worth every penny - Comfortable right out of the box (no break-in period!) And the red color is a nice deep red, perfect for autumn or anytime!

Very comfortable shoes but not sure if I like the look - kind of clunky looking when on.

I am a fond fan of Klogs Austin style and wanted to try another in the same size. I found this model to be tight across the top of my foot. It must be because of the straps. I will recommend to anyone that this brand tends to be bigger than the size. In fact, I find their wide sizes too wide too.

I love the look of theses clogs. I wear a 10W and that is what I ordered but these were very roomy. Even with an additional insert in them they slipped a bit.

The only real complaint I had about this shoe was the strap that goes over the top of my foot really started hurting the top of my foot. It's like it wasn't stretched out enough. I've tried wearing it a few times and it's still a problem. Other than that, I love the style of these shoes and love Klogs overall. I have three different pairs!

Great looking shoe. But the clog is very heavy, and pinches my bunion and presses against my high instep. Had to return it!

Are these the comfiest shoes for someone with a wider foot, no arch, tendency to roll inward, and plantar fasciitis? No, not the comfiest. But they're not causing more pain. They do tend to run a little narrower than others, however. I chose a Wide size like I usually wear, but discovered that it cuts into the top of my foot too much -- too tight. I'm hoping it'll stretch with more wear, and that seems to be working, but I could never wear anything more than thin socks with these. The length is pretty much spot on, however, and plenty of toe box room.

A large, heavy shoe, but at the same time, kinda feminine looking. Ran large for me. Am exchanging for a smaller size.

Love these shoes! I have had foot surgery and needed a shoe with great arch support. I am between a normal and wide, and the width in this shoe is perfect. Most comfortable shoes I own. Thank you Zappos.

I have wide feet, so these fit great. However, even after repeated wearings, the top strap is just too tight to wear more than a few hours. I was hoping this would stretch out but it hasn't. I love Klogs, they are super comfy in every other way. Their other styles fit me better than any shoe I've ever had. If you buy this style and the top band is too tight, return them; it won't loosen up over time.

I love these shoes so much, but unfortunately I have to send them back. They are ultra comfortable and cute, but they aren't adjustable and too wide. I wish they had a buckle like other mary janes to tighten them up a bit. If you have a narrow foot, you're out of luck!

I started out ordering a size 9 wide in these, which is what I normally wear. Returned them for a size 8.5 medium. Returned those for a size 8 medium to finally get the right fit. These are very comfortable. I was hoping to be able to wear them all day with less pain due to falling arches. They worked well for about 5 hours, after that my feet started to ache again. So, I would say they are a good stylish shoe for an evening out or 1/2 day short excursions. If you work in an office and are not on your feet all day (less than 5 hours), then these will work great for you. If you are a nurse and on your feet all day, I wouldn't recommend them. Loved the style, runs large, comfortable but not overly, convenient on/off, moderate arch support.

These are very cute and very comfortable if you do a lot of standing. Not so much walking if you have a longer second toe. The sizing is way off. I normally wear an 8 or 8½. The 7 extra wide fits perfectly.

No true rating in the support column because the shoe couldn't be properly tried on. A shame because it looks amazingly comfortable.

I ordered these in smooth black leather after having ordered a previous pair in blue patent leather. The blue ones fit perfectly out of the box, but the straps across the arch on the black ones have been a little too tight, resulting in unattractive swollen flesh between the toes and arch on top of the foot at the end of the day. I've tried stretching the leather, but don't want to break the elastic.