Customer Reviews Reef Smoothy

Definitely fit small. If you're in between sizes, go up. Overall a great sandal for the price.

I ordered three pairs of these in 8,9 and 10. I usually wear a men's 7. The 8's fit me..a little on the small side but the 9 was too big. My husband usually wears a 9 and had to take the 10's. Jury is still out on mine. The top strap is so tight I can barely wiggle my toes into them. Husband is wearing his which were also too tight but he says they're stretching out. I'm going to wait and see how much his stretch before I decide if Zappos get them back. I'm really disappointed in the new styling of these Reefs. I've been wearing these for many years. I love them because they are (were)wide and the straps don't rub. They have started making them narrower (I have duck feet) and cheaped out on that last 1/4 inch of fabric that they should have added to the straps. I will revise this review when I learn if they are going to stretch enough to fit my feet. These arrived within two days to Vermont. Love the free returns. Keeps me coming back.

These are a pretty comfortable, squishy style of cheap thongs. They have a bump in the arch area which is fairly unobtrusive (I prefer a flat sandle). They do feel really narrow for some reason. The only real negative at this price point is the sole. It's a harder rubber than usual, almost plastic feeling, and I noticed it was slippery on tile flooring. I think I will be returning these and intend on purchasing another pair of the slightly more expensive and lower profile Reef Cushions to alternate with the Clarks thongs I bought.

These are great. I wish they were wider. I wear a 9 2E but to make these fit I got a 12 and cut two inches off the heel.

I love Reef flip flops and they are all I'll ever wear. I ordered the same size Phantoms last year, and they fit a lot better than these. I figured a size 10 was a size 10, so I'm kind of disappointed.

This pair was purchased to replace an identical pair that was worn off and on for two years until it had nearly worn through. No other shoe would do.

Inexpensive, comfortable, lightweight. Great for around the house, patio, and pool. Order a full size larger than normal.

Order 2 sizes up. It took me two returns (which was so frustrating) to get the right fit for me. I normally wear a size 8....The size 10 of this fit me perfect.

Bought these for a friend who wears a 10. They were incredibly small, almost comically! Buy at least 1 size up to be safe.

Nice and comfy. Order one size larger, they run small.

Nice shoes with a good quality sole. Runs a bit long (probably 1/2 size bigger than regular shoe). So nice to find a flip flop in a big size!

Runs very small and narrow

Defective pair received. The right one fit perfect but the left ones strap was about an inch longer than the right and was very loose. Must have been a manufacturing error. Too bad because I liked them otherwise but I had to return them.

Men’s 11 ran very small. Have other pair of reef’s in 11 and fit fine. Had to return.