Customer Reviews Reef Smoothy

I'm size 11 and ordered that (August 2019), but they barely fit length and width wise. So I recommend ordering a half size up. Still comfy, slight amount of arch support. Last pair of Reef Smoothly lasted 7 years - so about $4 per year for flip flops if these hold out. They've got a lifetime customer if they can keep it up.

This style has been my favorite go-to flip-flop for at least a decade, but I've noticed over the past several years that they have been running decidedly smaller than when I first started wearing them. I normally wear a size 9 in most shoes, and a couple of years ago started ordering a size 10... But the last pair of these I ordered in a size 10 is borderline too small. (Holding them up to an older pair of this same style in the same size, they are more than ½" shorter, which is just... not great.) The web strap stretches out, and the footbed will flatten out as it breaks in and compresses, but it's not going to *spread* out very much if at all. Disappointing, but I will make it work for now. TLDR: Either these run super small, or Amazon & Zappos have accidentally shipped me something in a women's size the past 3 times I have ordered these. Size up at least one size (or 2 if you have wider feet.)

My husband has worn these for the past 20+ years. We normally buy at a surf shop, but couldn't find these exact ones so we decided to order from Zappos. He has a 9 1/2 wide foot and usually wears a 10, but these barely fit the length of his foot. Ordered a bigger size for him, will keep these for myself (they fit perfect and I wear an 8.5 women's).

Very comfortable, but runs small and a little narrow (compared to the previous Reefs I've owned along with the Sanooks I ordered in same size/width in this same order)

These sandals run extremely small. I wear a women's size 9, which would usually be a men's size 7. In these, I needed a men's size 9.

great simple flip flops. have held up well over time. comfortable too.

Been wearing them for years, would like the bottom be a little thicker and the arch.

The sole is thicker than I expected.

These are my husband's "go-to" sandal for casual wear and around the house activity. He's worn these for years and has gone through a few pairs because he wears them so much. The soles do get worn down over time, but for the price point and comfort level, these are a great sandal.

Classic sandal that still looks great after years of little change. I bought these to replace a pair of Reef Smoothies I bought in college 15 years ago. Hoping to get the same life span from these. They feel a little tight right now, but should break in after a few more weeks of use.

We had to order these two sizes up to get them to fit. This is not our first pair of Reefs (I've had 5 or 6 and so has my husband) but this is the first time we have ever had an issue with fit. I have to dock points just for that.

I usually wear a 12 but it was too small so I had to send back and get a 13. They seem really comfortable now. Thanks Zappos for the great service.