Customer Reviews Sofft Tyla II

Stylish and comfortable - For the longest time I was looking for the "perfect" black pair of boots and now I have found them. The shaft length is just right, the leather is very soft, the stitching on the back is a beautiful detail, but most of all they are very, very comfortable. I've worn them all day running around NY and have gotten many compliments. My only criticism is that the ankle is a little large, so I have to wear a thick sock.

This is a sexy boot that reaches up to a couple inches below the knee (I'm 5'10) and is loose enough in the calf for me to tuck my skinny jeans into. Fairly comfortable considering the heel height -- I'm a college student, and I can walk across campus in these without too much pain. Also, they keep my feet warm and dry.

Lovely wearable boot - Love this boot. It is somewhat less sexy than others, but infinitely more comfortable and very classy. Highly recommended!

Really Comfortable - I have an extremely wide foot but a thinner calf. This boot fit both, it was a definite keeper from the moment I put it on. It is true to wide width. The only change I would make would be to make the calf slightly smaller the arch support better, but it's not bad. Worth every penny.

I love these boots, but... I've been looking for that perfect pair of boots for YEARS and when I received these yesterday I thought I finally found them. I love everything about these: leather feels great, lining is soft which makes it so great to wear, boots are COMFORTABLE (and I can't wear most shoes without foot ache) and just looks great. Great quality compared to most boots that are on the market. But they're too big around my skinny calves! I'm so in love with these boots that if there was ANY way I can keep them I would, but with so much room around my calves I'm not sure that I can. I'm even considering going to a cobbler to see if there's any way they can fix it.

Great boot...if you’re tall enough. Ordered this boot and it was very comfortable. Very nice leather and nice color. Problem I encountered was that I am 5'1" and the shaft came up too high. When I walked or sat down, the back of it hit right behind my knees. I had to return them. =o (Wish Sofft made the same boot in a shorter length.

Beautiful boot, but larger around the calf. If you are a lady with womanly calves, these boots are amazing. Too bad for me, I have skinny legs. I love them, but they are very loose on the calve. My legs aren't even abnormally small or anything, I would say average. So keep that in mind. They are adorable and very comfortable though and felt true to size!

Gorgeous boots, but ankle too loose - I loved these boots, and wanted to keep them so badly, but the ankle area was just too loose and unflattering. I initially purchased the black maestro, so I am going to try the black suede to see if the suede material fits any more snugly...

Cute & very well made, but a little pinchy on the toes - I have 2 other pairs of Sofft shoes and definitely am happy with the quality and look of them. I knew by the pictures that these had a pointier toe than my other shoes, and they will hopefully break in a little more over time, as they are a little uncomfortable to stand in for a long time (my little toe is a little crunched). Overall though, they are very cute and well worth the money.

Very flattering boot - I really like this boot. I have a wider calf (16 inch) and these boots zip all the way up! My 23 year old daughter was hoping that they wouldn't... she wanted to take them off my hands! She thought they were "HOT". The heel is a good height and attractively stacked. It wears very comfortably. The leather is nice quality also. I'm pleased with the purchase... I think I'd like it in suede, too!

Beautiful shoes but too wide at the ankle - Beautiful shoe, soft leather, extremely comfortable but unfortunately too wide around the ankles - they looked baggy and had to go back for this very reason. Too bad, I am sure I would have loved the comfort.

Not for petite legs - Absolutely gorgeous. Both the suede and the calfskin feel like butter. Very comfortable and well constructed. Unfortunately, the circumference was a little too wide for my legs. They'd be great to wear over jeans or under wide-leg pants, but there was too much extra space to be able to wear them under straight leg jeans or with skirts.

Excellent quality boots - These boots are made with a very high-quality, luscious leather, with very nice lining. They are very comfortable, too. Slightly roomier than other boots I tried. I felt they looked a bit thick at the ankle - they would be more flattering if the ankle was more narrow.

WIDE shaft - This is a great-looking and comfortable boot. I saw that some reviewers thought the shaft was too wide, but I tried them anyway because I don't have skinny legs. Well, they're REALLY wide. The rest of the fit was perfect for me, but I wouldn't recommend these boots unless you have extremely athletic/large calves or you want to take them to a shoe repair shop to have them taken in.

Definitely Comfortable - I really like the comfort of this shoe and the braided seam down the back is a nice touch but the rounded toe is more "traditional" than I am looking for right now so I will be returning them. If I was going only for comfort, these would be keepers!

Lovely boot - I have wide, short toed feet and with that, comes a challenge to find footwear. These boots are lovely and comfortable.

The toe and everything about the boot is a lot rounder looking than I had expected so I'm returning them. They make my feet look big. They were comfortable though.

Nice shoe, not a great fit - Sofft makes a really nice shoe. These are quality boots. The sizing was accurate for me and these boots were very comfortable. However, the top of the boots were too wide, and it looked like I was a child trying on my mother's boots. I tried them on with jeans, and you could see shape of the wide top through the jeans - it looked very silly. So I have to return them. I wish they worked; there's a lot of nice qualities about this boot, but they didn't work for me.

Comfortable - This boot is easy to walk in, really doesn’t feel like it’s a 3" heel, looks really sexy and great with jeans. Nice leather and good arch support, too. I couldn’t get them, though, because the calves were much too big. They looked like galoshes at the top on me! I do have small calves, so skinnier calve ladies these might not work for you- for average or bigger, they will probably be great.

Beautiful boot - OK comfort - I fell in love with this boot when I saw it...and it's beautiful in person. Unfortunately, it did not work for my foot type at all. I have a pretty normal foot size/width. The boot was OK in the forefoot, but very loose in the ankle and heel. It felt wobbly when I walked. I am very used to wearing 3+ inch heels. I did not feel stable in the boots. I also question whether they could be worn any longer than a "non" comfort high heel boot. They are still worth giving a chance because they look great.

So soft, but tight in the calf - I bought these based on the reviews for the shoe being comfy...and it would have been, but it was pretty tight in my right calf. These definitely feel like they would be comfortable to wear all day, but not for the big-calf sisters.

These boots are so cute and seem like they would be very sexy. The fit was comfortable. However, this boot is definitely for people with wide calves. I have standard size calves and these boots were flopping around on my ankles and legs. I would have put up with it because they were comfortable and cute, but there was so much excess room that just walking around the house in them felt a little weird on my calves.

Peculiar fit - Guess I should have measured my calves! These were quite roomy and didn't fit my average-sized calves snugly. For a Wide Width, these boots are pinchy in the toe area, exacerbated by the pitch of the heel. The arch support was misplaced from the angle of the boot and felt non-existent. Just the whole shape of the boot was off for me. It's too bad, they look like nice little boots, but they are witchy-pinchy for those who need a nice roomy toe box.

Chunky - These boots fit beautifully and are very comfortable, but make my legs look like tree trunks. So, sadly, they have to go back.