Customer Reviews Sebago Plaza

An extremely good looking classic loafer with a great shine and good workmanship. Surprisingly, it has a decent arch. The craftsmanship on these shoes surpasses that of other brands. I have a wide foot, but not wide enough for a W width, so the loafer takes a bit of breaking in. I was hoping to get one with a tassel, but the quality of this loafer changed my mind.

Have been looking for another pair of penny loafers. Ordered 2 other pair thru Zappo's, did not work out, but these are great. Good fit, do not gap when I bend my food. The interior of finished for comfort. I have narrow heels and these fit so they do not slip when walking. I love them and very pleased. Great shoe.

Just got this shoe for Christmas. I had been wanting a penny loafer and this one looks and feels great. It has a rubber sole, but you can't really tell by looking at it. I wore it to the mall the day after Christmas to do my returns/exchanges and had no problems with blisters. I did wear a thin pair of socks with them. They are a nice classic looking loafer. I wear a size 7.5 or 8 and went with the 8 and they feel great. I have a pretty standard arch and width and they are fine. Overall, a great shoe, esp. for the money!

Very versatile shoe and it is just like in the photo. The deep brown color goes with all my dresses and jeans. It is extremely comfortable and soft. Usually when I buy boots or sport shoes I buy a size 7 or 7.5 for more comfort. My size is 6 and this shoe of size 6 fits me well with socks or without socks. I did buy a loafer of size 6.5 and had to return it back as it was too large.

Have had these shoes over a year. Great fit and great wear and comfort! Thank you Zapppos.

They are a very clean and classy looking loafer and look great with skirts, dress pants, and even make a pair of jeans dressy. My daughter always wears her loafers barefoot because it makes my shoes look more feminine, she says these are really smooth and comfortable adainst her skin.

Sebago Plaza-Great look, fit & comfort - I have been looking for quite some time for penny loafers. Finally found them at Zappos. It is a great style that works for business causual and just plain casual. I love them!

Great loafer. Will like it even more when it is broken in a bit. If you enjoy wearing loafers you will love this one.

This is the best shoe I've ever worn. I have three or four pair I like them so much! The shoe is comfortable and feels great on my feet, gives me the support I need and just fits perfectly. The only problem I am having is that in two of the pair I own, the right shoe ran considerably narrower than the left. These shoes were purchased several months, even a year or more apart, so I assume it's not a batch problem. My mother has balance and walking problems and is presently wearing SAS velcro shoes. I am going be buying a pair for her to try because of the comfort, support and ease of slipping on and off. This is a shoe which I will continue to buy this shoe as long as it is available. I couldn't ask for more.

Although slightly tight at first, they loosen up and then fit perfectly. Are very comfortable and easy to slip on, my new favorite shoes.

My lady friend loves them! They fit well and she likes the feminine look. Comfort and style, who can ask for more? It was just a smidge narrower than she would like, but they will stretch enough to compensate for that.

I have to say that this is most comfortable shoe I have ever owned. I have been wanting a pair of Penny Loafers for years and these shoes will last years. They are so well made and extremely comfortable. The support is also good. I love them and Zappos service is superb. I got them the next day after placing my order.

I love these shoes. This is my second pair. The first pair wore so well and stayed nice looking, that when they wore out, I bought the same again.

Wanted to buy shoes in reminisce of my childhood as casual work shoes. I saw these and fell in love. Though the picture shows them to be more "shiny" and more dressy in style, the leather is actually broken in and soft, like a boat shoe.

Not everyone can be counted upon to keep their promises, but Zappos keeps theirs! I am so pleased with them, I intend to do a lot more shopping with them. By the way, I love my shoes! They are so well made and are beautiful!

I had been looking for penny loafers forever; nobody local had them. Zappos did. Free shipping, they arrived promptly, they are beautiful. I would recommend Zappos anytime.

Great supple leather shoe with lots of support. 7B feels true to size. Worth the price. As always, Zappos sends out within a day.

A great, traditional penny loafer. My daughters wear them with their parochial school uniforms. They are well made and still looked terrific after the entire school year of daily wearing!

Great shoe! Easy to wear from the beginning (I did have to order a 1/2 size up). Color is great for spring/summer/fall.

I have been looking for traditional-style loafers for quite a while and was delighted to find them. I need to wear orthotics for a bunion so I always have issues with shoes being deep enough to accommodate the orthotics and still stay on my feet. These fit the bill. They are slightly snug with the orthotics but are gradually loosening up a bit with wear and don't rub on my instep or heel. These shoes help me maintain a clean, professional look without the pain of high heels. If you want a classic look, give these a try. Thanks too to Zappos--your service cannot be topped!

The she was beautiful and appeared to be high quality, however I ordered a 10W which is my usual size and I was barely able to squeeze my foot into the shoe. I was very narrow, I would say more narrow than the typical medium width. I was so disappointed, however Zappos return process was painless, as usual.

Have worn Sebago loafers for years but was unable to find them locally. Glad to find them again on Zappos.

I have a wide foot so I ordered regular size but in wide and they were perfect. These shoes are soft and didn\'t require any break in time. They are now the most comfortable shoes in my closet.

These are great shoes. They are true to size and very comfortable. They also wear well, if you are hard on your shoes.