Customer Reviews Foamtreads Coddles

Great shoes - Got these for my Mom for her birthday. She loves them. Good fit.

Good, solid slipper - I was looking for a slipper with a real back on it, as many of them now are the open back style and these are a problem for me on our stairs at home. This is a good comfortable slipper with good traction. It's washable and comes in several attractive colors.

I wear a size 10.5 and few slippers are available in this size. In this case, customers are usually advised to buy 1/2 size up. I bought a pair of Foamtread Coddles last year in a size 11. They worked out all right as far as the fit is concerned. Halfway through the winter season I had to add an insole because the slippers stretched and became unpleasantly loose. By the end of the season, they were worn out. This fall I ordered another pair in a size 11, and they just about fell off my feet. There has been a change made in the sole of the shoe which may account for this. I switched to a 10, which seems to be all right. Before the Froamtread Coddles I had other Foamtreads (always the same model) which were far superior in fit, looks, and overall quality to the Coddles. Unfortunately, they are no longer available. I do not remember the name of that model. The upper fabric of the current Coddles shows wear much quicker than my former Foamtreads and also seems to stretch out a little quicker. Furthermore, the color selection of this Coddles is definitely were "bedroomy." Navy (and it is a faded looking navy) is the best of the lot, and not fantastic. I am retired and spend many hours at home. I want a slipper that has good shape, does not fit too loosely, and has a well-defined and more sturdy sole than is often the case. Coddles comes close, but is certainly not as good as the previous, no longer available model. This also goes for the color selection.

I didn't like these at all. Although the foot bed was very thick, it felt hard and stiff. My right foot is 1/2 size larger than the left, and in these slippers the back of the smaller foot slipped up and down and the toes of the larger foot felt tight.

Although I am wearing these and they help cushion me from my hardwood floors, the memory foam is not really much at all. I don't really feel it. But that's ok. I can handle that and my feet feel supported enough. I wouldn't want too much cushion anyway. What I really do not like is that they have a fishy smell. I only noticed this after wearing for a few days. Haven't considered returning them but I will let Zappos know about this.

I normally wear a 10.5 to 11 wide. I felt by ordering an 11 wide I would have plenty of room, but these went on tight and honestly they did not appear to be a wide size even though the box said wide, the shoe itself had no indication of being marked as a wide as far as I could tell. It very much appeared to be an average width. I liked the slipper, but the size was off the mark for me.

Zero arch support, so I returned them.

These are cute slippers, but they were WAY too small. I generally wear an 8 wide, and this slipper felt much smaller than that. I did get my foot in one of them, but I am sure they would have split open if I tried to actually walk in them. I am returning these.

These slippers are made of quality materials, but the sizing - length and width - is very off. After trying my normal size, 1/2 size up and then 1/2 size up in wide (which I have never worn) - I gave up. The toe area is very small and due to the soft fabric, there is nothing to hold your toe in place - it then slips over the sole of the shoe. Perhaps these are best for extremely narrow feet? I wear UGGs slippers in the winter, but was looking for something that would be cooler in the summer months.

Pretty, but too small for me.

They are comfy slippers, but are pretty tight - I returned them for a size bigger than my usual & they are still snug. The foam is nice, but looses its cushyness after a while. Overall, I still like them, but wasn't as thrilled as I was hoping to be.

I bought these for my mother in a nursing home. I have taken them for myself because she could not keep them on her feet. The heel area was not as firm and supportive as I thought they might be. However, I did end up with a new pair for myself.

Foamtread’s coddles - I love the slippers - bought them a size larger, based on other reviews. They were true to size - should have bought my normal size.

Too small - I'm usually 7 1/2 to 8 shoe. I ordered the 8 and I feel it is almost a whole size too small. So I say order up a size, but the shoe is soft and looks fine. No arch support. Great for around the house, but price point too high. I would not order again.

Very pretty, but definitely feel smaller than marked. I will keep them to wear when I have company staying over, but not for when I want to be comfy around the house on winter weekends.

This shoe was small and heavy for a slipper. I am returning it for a half size bigger. It will be good for trips outside on our gravel pathways. It seems to be very well made.

Did not like the fit at all!! Foamtreads really changed, seem to be made cheaper. I previously wore Foamtreads for many years. Sorry, they changed their fit.

Not for me. I need a "shoe" that I can wear inside that gives a moderate amount of support. This one doesn't.

These slippers definitely run small. I tried my normal size and the next half-size up. Couldn't wear either one.

They run small - definitely buy a half size larger than your shoe size. They are not well made - very poor quality especially for the price. I would say - move on - don't bother with them.

Slippers - My mom wanted comfortable slippers with good arch supports for Christmas, and I bought her these based on other reviews. Unfortunately, they are going back because they ran very small and did not have good arch support. She normally wears an 8W, and I bought a 9W since some people said they ran small. Nevertheless, they were still too tight and uncomfortable for her (I wear an 8 or 8 1/2 regular and they were too tight for me too). She has a high instep, and the band cut into the top of her foot, and while they were heavily cushioned, there was no real support. Love Zappos, just not the slippers!

I'm so disappointed that the insole has been changed. They did this a while ago, but when I saw the video, it has the previous insole which was cloth, I thought I'd get a new pair of slippers (with the cloth insole). The current insole is the worst because it sticks to my feet unless I wear socks. It's some kind of rubber or plastic. Zappos needs to update the video. Below is what the insole looks like now.

These slippers were like outdoor shoes with heavy soles...not like slippers at all. Returned them...not what I had in mind.