Customer Reviews Foamtreads Coddles

These were lovely but too long and narrow to accommodate my foot shape. For my feet the slippers were just wide enough but too long to be comfortable. I also have a high instep and the band over the top of the foot was snug. Details about why these didn't fit me - I have very wide yet short feet (women's 7 D or E width). I can often get away with a rounded toe 7.5 W if the toe bed is wide enough and the heel not too narrow.

I sized up a half size due to recommendations and slipping off heels when I walk. Sending back.

I'm on the fence with these. They should be comfortable but truly feel almost 1/2 size too small. Am thinking since somewhat stretchy fabric they could fit if stretched out a bit?? IDK

A little too long. Slipped up and down on the heel. Had a previous pair which were perfect and totally wore them out..

A little disappointed with these slippers. I was looking for something for around the house to slip my feet into at the end of the day. These have a very hard and sturdy sole and felt more like a shoe than a slipper. Thank you Zappos for letting me return them.

I've worn this exact pair of slippers for a number of years. I've gone through multiple pairs and they're very comfortable and cute -- by far my favorite slippers ever. However the last pair I received were very different than what was pictured on the website. I was expecting terrycloth on the inside of the slipper like they've always had, but the ones I received had a bizarre leathery material on the inside of the sole (where the bottom of your feet go) that sticks to the skin on the sole of my foot and is extremely uncomfortable!

I have had these slippers in the past and loved them. I wish your current style came in double wide and that is why I had to return them.

I love Zappos shoes normally. But this pair of Coddles was sloppy loose in all directions. I walked right out of them. They had so little padding it was hard to just stand in them - zero comfort.

Dang! they changed this shoe! I've worn these slippers for a decade. Just got a new pair and there's a new kind of insole and the fit was really sloppy! So sad - must return.

These slippers fit very well but the foot bed was hard, not something you would want to walk around in all day.

Cute slipper that doesn’t scream “House shoes!” Nice fabric & good support.

This was too big & too narrow. There is some arch support, so I will try the next smaller size.

I purchased a pair of these slippers in April of 2020 and just love them. As a result, I just ordered the identical item but the slippers that arrived today are NOT the same slipper. These slippers are bigger (about a 1/2 size) than the originals and both the insole and sole are different. The sole on this slipper is quite slippery. As a result, these new slippers are going back. Very disappointed! Changes made were definitely not for the better.

I ordered these for my mother in law, who has a bunion. We ordered up a size and wide. They didn’t work at all well.

The soles on these slippers are surprisingly heavy and stiff. Almost like wearing wedges. Not what I'm looking for in slippers, so will be returning them.

Nice looking slippers. I ordered size 9, wide width, and they fit fine. But I am 72 and I didn’t feel like they gave me the support that I needed.

I ordered my regularly shoe size of 8 1/2 but they feel a full size too small. Sent back but didn’t swap at this time. May think about ordering again later. I did like the style Ok, but I didn’t love them

I was so excited to get these slippers. They are comfortable but don't stay on my feet when I walk they slip off.

Slipper was short in length, but felt ordering a size up would be too large. Returned them.

I really wanted to love these slippers. Originally ordered my regular size and they were too small, exchanged for half size bigger, now they are too big. Love the color and the style but won’t buy this brand again.

Slippers were too big and not as cushy as I had hoped.

I was disappointed with these slippers. The style is okay for something you wear around the house in private. But the soles were not nearly as cushy and padded as other Foamtreads I've tried. Love that they are washable, but not enough to keep them.

I have narrow feet, and these slipped off of my heels. They were also a little heavier than I expected, and I noticed a strange odor coming from them as another viewer also mentioned.

These were too small and tight I usually wear a size 8. I ordered 8.5 and still too small. I have ordered a size 9 which is on backorder. I was really disappointed as the slipper is very nicely made.

The insole isn’t flat, it’s higher in the heel area (and tight fitting) and it is also too hard, not comfortable. The rest of the insole is fine.