Customer Reviews Sperry Billfish 3 Eye

This shoe is nice in all respects, except for one fatal flaw (probably a manufacturing rather than a design defect): The inside of the left shoe where two pieces of leather/fabric are stitched together (about 1/3 from the front) has a rather spikey protrusion, which has been irritating my foot (redness and blistering). I waited for for a few months for the shoe to be broken in, wore the shoe with and without socks, to no avail. Interestingly enough, the right shoe is just fine. Unfortunately, I have to throw this pair away.

Extremely uncomfortable. Cut the back of my heels open after wearing them once on a workday.

I bought this pair of shoes 6 months ago, and the leather insole is separating from the foam base glued inside the shoe. They have become extremely uncomfortable and impossible to keep from blistering my feet. The leather inside is curling up and it constantly feels like you have something stuck on the medial side of your foot inside the shoe. I have a pair of sperrys that are 6 years old and are still great. Evidently they are like many other companies and have started to make a cheaper lower quality product.

Although this shoe is stylish and fits fairly well, I have had to return two pairs due to defects. The first pair I received had eyelets come loose. The second pair's arch support padding curved near the toes, after a few times wearing them. I was suppressed that a fairly pricey shoe from Sperry would have all these problems. I probably would not buy Sperry's again. Thankfully Zappos is great about returns and standing behind what they sell.

This shoe fell apart in a couple weeks and once the insole began to fall apart, it became very uncomfortable to wear. Way overpriced for the quality of the product.

I figured out that a sandals or crocks do the best when out on the water in my boat, even barefoot. I ordered the Sperry Topsiders to be a little bit more stylish when I am out boating but they just didn't feel right on my feet, maybe cause i wear a 13, who knows, but I'm sure this shoe is great for small footed people. Oh well looks like i get to save the money for more fishing gear. other than that the size was true and the width was just OK. But I wanted to see what the hype was all about with these shoes, The comfort hasn't changed since the first time I've tried out this type of shoe back in the '90's but like i said this shoe is for smaller feet. =)

Cheap shoes. Yes, they are comfortable. Yes, they are cool and so mainstream if you want to look like every other college kid because you're insecure. For the price, I would expect much better. The leather is so cheap that I can imagine it falling apart in a matter of months, and after only having them for about a month, the sole is beginning to separate from the sole in the front. Honestly, I would be completely satisfied if these shoes were about half this price. But they are not, and are thus a rip-off. Be a man and get some Aldos. They are on the cheaper side and are of solid quality, not to mention cool.

While this shoe does look great it does lack in comfort in big ways. There is absolutely no heel support. These shoes also make a squishing noise as you walk in them if you don't buy different insoles for the shoe.

Classic.

Best everyday, casual shoe around!

Nice look, good support, true to size.

I have worn these shoes over the years. This pair was very much larger than anticipated This is an excellent product, just a bad fit.

Fit great! Very nice boat shoes.

Awesome

The xw was a bit too wide. Went back to wide. Great shoe good classic quality

If you have flat feet the arch supports are going to be a bit painful. Unfortunately I'll be returning them.

Stylish shoe, runs small

had to exchange size 11 for a 10.5... no problem with exchange...easy to buy from.

Fit and comfort are what I expected.

These are my favorite casual shoes.