Customer Reviews Sperry Billfish 3 Eye

Was disappointed in these shoes. The toe was very square, and the color was muddy compared to the Sebago boat shoes I also ordered. Fairly comfortable, but returned them in favor of the Sebagos.

I have had several pairs of these through the years. Size and width are as advertised. Arch support is considerably better than the original moccasin but not great. Fine on a boat or around the docks but not for prolonged walking or standing around.

At first I feared it was a bit small but it has broken in and is comfortable. After a week I'd recommend these shoes.

I've never needed to buy a wide shoe before. I've always been fine with standard width. But with these the toes (really the front third of the shoe) was too narrow. So I suggest trying your regular size but wider than you usually take. They need some break-in time—the left shoe has been cutting into my ankle a little, but I think it'll break in pretty soon. The style is great and the materials are nice. I don't think they're great walking shoes. I wouldn't want to walk all over town with them, but for shorter walks they're fine.

These are much lighter in color than they appear on the website. Rather disappointing.

I purchased a size 10.5 XW (extra wide). They are still too narrow and almost borderline to short as well. I marked the rating as "excellent arch support" but in reality it is too much arch support for my feet. I still like the shoe and might consider this or a similar style in a larger size. Hopefully I can find a wider version.

Love these shoes. Just bought a new pair to replace the ones I've had for a few years. Very comfortable, great on the boat or for daily wear. The one down side? Sizing inconsistency. I bought the exact same shoe in the exact same size and these ones are about ½" longer than the ones I already had. Unfortunately, I put them on the day the arrived and wore them all day, so didn't seem right to return them worn that much, but you're better buying these in a store where you can try them on.

Now in my 5th or 6th pair over the last twenty or so years, these are the standard, good casual and boating shoes. Originally made in USA with far superior comfort and quality but like all manufacturers, Sperry has sent their production to the lowest (cheapest) bidders and the shoes have come from China, SE Asia, and now Dominican Republic. The leather seems much thinner and I hope the quality holds up. As others have written, the fabric along the sides eventually gives out and splits and on the last pair, even the laces became cheaper and no longer stay tied - have to double knot them like mother used to. They still have that superior Sperry sole and are reasonably comfortable for sockless wear. Whatever happened to American quality? Used to be the best in the world.

Fit is true to size and style is what you would expect. Purchased "Dark Tan" which was not as dark as pictured. Would put the color half way between light and dark (as pictured). Nice shoe, reasonably comfortable but not out of the box. Requires some break in time but then is fine.

Good quality shoe with internal heal pad. Ran big so had to return for a smaller size.

Pretty comfy given the generous padding. Insole is not removable. My only complaint is the toe box is too narrow even in a wide. I compared these to a pair of SAS shoes and there was no question. Had I not compared the two I probably would have kept these, but the others are just more flexible, cushioned, and have lots of toe room. These are also quite heavy for a boat shoe.

They were great but totally fell apart after 5 months of less than daily wear.