Customer Reviews Naturalizer Creston

At first I thought these shoes were comfortable, but as soon as I started walking around in the house, I realized that like shown in the picture, the toe curls up. Now maybe after wearing for some time, it would flatten out, but I do not want to have to break in a shoe so it doesn't curl up like an elf shoe. These will be going back!

My first time with a flat shoe made this way. But I trusted the Naturalizer brand. Shoes I buy on Zappos are mostly for work. This shoe is absolutely fantastic. So comfortable all day at the same time giving me the support I need. Definitely buy it, you will not be sorry!

Oh my goodness. I was so excited to get a semi-decent looking flat in an 8 (WW). I couldn't believe that it was extremely narrow; even moreso than a normal size 8 (B). The reviews on this shoe were excellent. I'm sad that it didn't even come close to working out (and yes, I checked the box and the shoe to make sure it was a WW that I received).

Darn, they really do dig into the top of the foot along the tendon of the big toe. So sad, because they do seem like they'd be comfy otherwise, and they are good looking.

I should have believed earlier reviews that the toe of the shoe tilts up and is curved so it makes my toe push up on the front top of the shoe. Soft leather, nice color but that weird tilt makes it a return for me. Could have had better arch support but at least they had a tiny one.

I was so excited to get the shoes and start to break them in before a trip. 1 day with minimal walking and my heels and toes were bleeding from how they rubbed. Originally ordered a size smaller but felt uncomfortably tight, so I went a size up. Maybe should have kept to smaller size to minimize the rubbing? Adorable looking shoes, but now terrified to wear due to how much damage they did to my feet. Definitely have potential to be very comfy, but not sure worth the pain to get to that point.

Nice quality but where the heel tab hits on back of ankle is irritating and uncomfortable.

Disappointed. I previously had a pair of these shoes in brown and they were like wearing slippers! tried these thinking they'd be great for all the plane travel i'm doing this year but found them very tight across the top of my foot. even my husband commented that they looked tight. not going to risk them not stretching properly and back they go!

These were stiff all around and tight at the base of my toes. They were also scratchy at the seams on the heel.

I was thrilled when I found a ballet-type flat in a AAA. That said, I have found the shoe rubs on my heel. I really want to like this shoe. It is comfy in all other ways. Width and length are good. Overall shoe construction seems fine. Unfortunately this shoe just rubs me in all the wrong places...literally!

Wide Enough! These shoes are simple and practical. Not what I'd love to be wearing, but the EE was wide enough for my wide feet PLUS my orthodics that are now a daily requirement. I don't think there is much arch support, but I needed to remove the Nat. insole to place my orthotic anyway.

I work in retail, have a WW foot and a high arch. I ordered this shoe based on other reviews, but was sadly disappointed. It was tight and the top of my foot spilled out over the top of the shoe.

Cute and possibly worth the blister - I haven't worn actual shoes in years. I've lived in Rainbow flip flops and Crocs for the last few years of my life along with Uggs!!! I had two ankle surgeries in June and have been having trouble finding a shoe that fits my already wide feet! These seemed cute enough, and they really were when I got them. I tried them on right away and they seemed pretty comfy and not bad looking to throw on with jeans. The back didn't start to rub funny until after wearing them for at least 4 hours. I took them off to find a blister on the back of my left ankle. I like them so much though that I'm just going to buy blister bandaids to wear back there cuz these shoes are like walking on pillows!

Cute, but sized oddly - I really like the looks of these shoes, but unfortunately, even getting the size I usually wear and have worn for years in Naturalizers they slip at the heels and I haven't figured out how to solve this problem yet. Having very narrow feet, I find it difficult to get shoes that are functional and attractive in an 8AAA. If I can solve the problem, I'll order them in another color.

Pretty but not much arch support - This shoe is very pretty and the size is an accurate fit but there isn't much arch support. As usual, the service from Zappos was terrific!!

Not wide enough - Even though I ordered these in a wider width, they still had to be stretched to make them comfortable.

Cute but OUCH! Very cute shoe. Much better in person than in the picture. However, the elasticized back portion digs into my foot. I can't wear these shoes for more than an hour without blisters at the backs of my feet. Sure band-aids help, but when the shoe is supposed to be the "comfy" shoe - what good is it really?

Way too small - The shoe looked cute but it was about a half size too small.

Shoes started out comfortable, but as my feet began to swell the shoes became very tight in the toe area!! They were too narrow in the front area and became very tight.

Comfy Naturalizer shoe - I often have trouble finding an attractive shoe that also feels comfortable. This shoe not only is cute, but also comes in several colors and it feels great from the start. I have a wide toe box and thought my toes might be crunched, but they felt fine. I'd definitely recommend this shoe to others.

Too Wide - I wear a 7 ½ AAA or 8 AAA, a difficult size to find in cute comfortable shoes. I was so disappointed when I received this shoe because it was too unbelievably wide to be an AAA width. I have just returned the two pairs that I ordered in this style. I am thankful that shipping is free; it makes the experience much more pleasant when making a return.

Cute shoes, but PAINFUL - I took a chance and bought these shoes in black even after reading all the reviews that talked about how the back of the shoes dig into the wearer's heel. They were really comfortable for the first 10 minutes, then the back of the shoes started to dig into my feet, rubbing the skin off. I had some moleskin pads with me and I put them on my feet. By the end of the day, the back of the shoes ended up digging and chaffing off most of the moleskin and nearly scraped a hole all the way though. Cute shoes, but I definitely will be wearing socks and band-aids next time.

HURTS HEAL - I agree with Georgia. When you first try them on, they feel very comfortable. After wearing them for only an hour, they dig into your heels. I made the mistake of buying these in 3 colors... I returned these, but I'll try socks with the others... not thrilled about that though, given they are supposed to be slip-ons. Oh well.

When you first try them on they feel very comfortable but after wearing then for only an hour they dig into your heels. I tried to give them a second, third, and fourth chance but each time my heel just throbbed.