Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Classic II

Absolutely beautiful BUT painful across the big toe joint and a bit of heel slippage ..........I wanted to love these but couldn't. Returned.

Love the style. Purchased my regular size but these were too tight across the area across where my toes begin. Thought maybe they might stretch as I wore them but it was much too painful to wear. Ao back they go.

I’ve been looking for some sort of basic loafer for forever, but they never seem to come in wide width, so I was really excited to see that this one does. Sadly, the shoe looked and felt normal width, despite being marked 8.5W. Really disappointed.

I did not care for the material

This was rubbing on my heel, slipping off, just a little too big. Didn't look like great quality either.

I wanted to like this shoe but did not - it just did not deliver the classic penny loafer look I was after.

the color is way darker than tje picture. it’s almost coffee brown. Not what I anticipated ??

Too small and narrow. pretty shoes, too bad I have to return them.

I wanted to love these shoes but they have a strange cut to them. Narrow at the toes and wide in the middle of the shoe. No arch support whatever! Sorry, I have to return these.

These loafers in a wide width are only wide in the heel. The front of the shoe is still rather narrow. The heel is so big they fall off my feet in the back with every step I take. I tried going down a half size, but those were too short in the toe area and still loose in the heel. They are great-looking shoes, but sadly I have to return them.

Very long and no support.

Far too narrow for a medium foot. I thought maybe it had been mislabeled. Returned.

Looks like plastic though it says it is not. Also some weird mark on side of shoes

Classic loafer which I love, but too tight across top of the foot and very loose in the heel.

The fit is true to size, but the material looks like cheap plastic. Would not repurchase.

Already written a review. Misshapen Left shoe. And sent photos. Shoes are being returned for a replacement…including the broken box.

I’m very disappointed. The toe box was cramped, even in a wide. The plasticky “leather” finish started to flake off at the seams after a few wears making them look too shabby for the office. I tossed them in the trash.

The fit was truly ODD! The right foot was loosey goosey and the left foot was a good fit. Definitely not a match with size.

These are comfortable, but they’re really cheap and they run huge.

Poor fit, poorly made, weird feel to leather Definitely not how I remember Eastland

The top, where the toes live, is so hard and painful. I couldn't even wear them all day!

This shoe was so small I couldn’t get my foot in it! Returning.

The fit and size were fine, however the leather was very stiff and they looked very cheap.

The shoe ran very small.

These were almost comical. They were tiny, tiny, tiny. I always wear a 7 or 7 1/2, I went with a 7 1/2 and decided to get a wide width as the last pair of Eastlands I've had were a bit narrow. I couldn't even come close to getting my feet into these shoes. They are at least two sizes too small, maybe 3 sizes too small. Zappos stellar shipping, returns and customer service makes this an easy return.