Customer Reviews KEEN Calistoga

Keen Calistoga - Nice MaryJane shoe. This is my 6th pair of Keens and they seem to have fixed their sizing issue of the past 2 years. Order your regular size. No sizing up is needed with this shoe. My only complaint is that the arch support isn't as good as my other Keens. I use different insoles in these. Rum raisin is a nice alternative to brown. Overall another great shoe from Keen!

Flamingo is NOT pink! LOVE these shoes, but was hesitant to buy them online because when it said the color was "Flamingo" and I was thinking pink. Well, they are NOT pink - they are gorgeous! The color is a deep peach or orange. Some might say "persimmon". Either way, they are very pretty and oh so comfy! I just bought the deep lichen Keen Berkeley shoes, too!

Great comfy shoes! First, quick background: I am 48 with arthritis in my knees. I can no longer wear heels (at least not any new ones, I wear granny shoes from the 30's and 40's with 2 inch heels). I dress for comfort and I LOVE these shoes. Only one thing, the color in reality is MUCH lighter than in the picture which was disappointing as I really prefer dark shoes.

Love my Keens - I ordered these shoes from a recommendation by 2 friends who have them & love them - now I am in the position to spread the word. They are great!

You won't be disappointed - I've been needing some good, comfortable shoes to work in (photographing weddings), and to also be my everyday shoes running around with my small children. I am very happy with these Keen's. I also have a pair of Sydney II's in 8.5, which is the same length as Calistoga's 8. I know a lot reviews say that you have to go up in size, but I found that the 8 (which is my average size) was a true 8. These are very cute (I have them in Flamingo and they really go with the majority of my wardrobe), and they are ideal for anyone with a simple, even earthy style - sporty too, but not overly so.

Comfortable and practical - I usually wear a C width, so I did have these stretched before wearing. Once I did that, they were fine. I had a 4 day training in another city and walked everywhere. These were the perfect shoe. More of a sporty look, but I'd rather dress down a bit and be comfortable.

Perfect shoe! Have been looking for a shoe to wear with dresses and jeans and this fits the bill! Plenty of toe room, good looking, and really comfortable. This is my 2nd style of Keens and I'm going to order another style.

Good all around shoe - I spend a lot of time on my feet during work and this shoe is great as it is comfortable as well as cute enough to wear with pants and casual skirts.

LOVE THESE SHOES! These are the MOST comfortable shoes I have ever had. I wear them morning 'til night. I have a pair of Keen sandals that I had to get a half size larger, but these are my exact size, so I would recommend ordering your true size. Zappos was great with size exchange...so fast! Highly recommend both the shoes and Zappos.

Great Shoes - These are great shoes. I am usually a brown shoe lover, but I decided to try the rum raisin. I am so glad. I love the color. Also some of the reviews said the shoe ran a little big. I did not find this the case. Another great Keen shoe.

Love them! I am always searching for a truly comfortable shoe that is practical for my lifestyle and this is it! I have them in different colors and plan on getting more.

Love this shoe! 6 years ago I was in a bad car accident and my right ankle was crushed. I have traumatic arthritis in my ankle. These are the most comfortable shoes that I own, even more so than my tennis shoes!

Cute shoe, not so comfortable - I love the look of this shoe, but it isn't as comfortable as I expected it to be for the price. All of the other reviews said how comfortable they are, but I have not had that experience. There isn't much of an arch support. The bottom of my heels hurt for a couple of days after I first wore them. They are little more comfortable now, but I really wanted a shoe I could wear for hours without my feet hurting.

Keens deliver again - I own 4 pairs of Keen shoes. All comfortable, all good quality. The Calistogas are no exception. I have narrow feet, and I did have to add a thick sole insert to take up space in the open vamp area. I love that they are more closed and dressy than the sandals but still open enough to wear in warmer weather.

Perfect all rounder mary janes - This shoe is perfect for Summer and Spring wear with clothes that you want to wear without socks. I would waterproof the shoe for my climate in Oregon just to make myself feel better about protecting the finish. I bought seal brown, black and rum raisin (everyone loves that color). It will go with skirts, jeans, cropped pants, dresses and shorts. I bought them to wear on my Santa Fe trip later this year. They'll go with all my travel wear and the tread will be great for all day walking and exploring. I want 1 pair of shoes to take for the entire trip (I just have to choose which ones to take!). The colors are great although the rum raisin is more a brown than red. I would love to see it in a natural/neutral light color, too. I wear an 8.5 shoe (a 39 in Dansko) and this shoe in 8.5 is big. It's wearable but I will wear insoles with it just for more comfort and a tighter fit. If you want a closer fit an 8 would be better. I have the Keen Venice 2 sandal and I had to get that in a 9! Calistoga does feel wide but great if you don't want the shoe to rub. The strap is very supportive and easy to get buckled up. It's a great looking shoe, does look wide but as always "cute". Great shipping practice Zappos and the phone staff are excellent!! This shoe was $4 more at Zappos than my local store but the shipping and return policy was enough to get me to buy from Zappos. Thanks.

The best urban walking shoes - Although they seem a tad larger than I anticipated, with a good pair of socks the shoes are fantastic. I can wear them all day and have the arch support and cushion I need. A great buy! Also, the Zappos’ customer service was exceptional!

Comfy and cute - I love these shoes. I bought them to travel to Europe this spring. They ran about a half size large for me so I had to exchange them. They were comfortable from the moment I put them on!! They can be casual or dressed up with a skirt.

An Instant Classic - I love this shoe! My search for the perfect dress shoe is over at last! These shoes are versatile: they look great with jeans or dress, and I have received numerous compliments on them. These are super classy without being trendy and go with everything. They seem to be well-made, with good leather, and I'm sure I'll be wearing them for years. If you have a wide foot consider ordering a half-size larger, but despite the pointy toe, they don't pinch like many others I have tried. (Another plus: no toe-cleavage!) A classic. Zappos customer service gets an A+!

Rum Raisin - This shoe is very nice and comfy. Runs true to size length wise, but a little on the wide side. These run more true to size then the Seattle, which for me was a whole size to short in length. Nice to know that they have resized to fit more accurate. Very nice color, rum raisin, it's good to have comfort with a stylish mary jane.

Very Happy - I love my new Calistoga shoes. They are very comfortable and fit well.

Not worth the money - I used to have the Keen Vancouver, I think it was. It was the plain black Mary Jane that is slender when compared to the Seattle. I loved that shoe & wore it with everything for at least 3 years, until it got a hole in the sole & couldn't be repaired. I ordered the Calistoga in green as a replacement & got it yesterday. I'll be sending it back. Basically, it doesn't look like 95 bucks worth of shoe. The pair I got has a chunk of glue on the leather near the toe, & there is zero support. I would normally put in your basic $10 insert anyway, but the whole shoe just hit in odd places on my foot & felt cheaply made. I had looked at some locally earlier in the week & they all looked as if they were hastily made. I suspect they are farming out their manufacturing even more over time to increase their profit, & spending less on the actual shoe. It shows, I can tell you. I did buy a pair of the Keen sneakers for my little boy just yesterday, at a local store. They seem fine. The Keen line has a good name, mostly based on their closed-toe sandal, which I do think is a fine shoe. I would say- you will have to evaluate each model in this line individually. Their quality is becoming just slightly erratic.

Great shoe - I bought them for a trip and have been wearing them every day for 3 solid weeks now, and they are really comfortable. They also go with everything, which is what I wanted. My only complaint is that I bought my true size, and they are a little big.

True to Size - Tried these on at a shoe store and was surprised that they fit! In length true to size, however wide in width. They are very cute, although somewhat Mickey Mouse-ish wide toe box. But I did find that the buckle was impossibly hard to fasten. Decided to go with the Sydney ll, the fit was narrower in the heel and forefoot. The buckles worked a lot better too!

Great fit for wide feet - I have really wide feet (2E) and these shoes fit great and don't pinch. They're comfortable to wear for hours on end and nice to walk in too. These shoes are also pretty cute.

Fancy Tire-Treads - Keen's Calistoga Hybrid shoes in rum raisin, were my first purchase from Zappos, and I couldn't be happier. They fit perfectly, and I am hard to fit (size 11, narrow to med.) They are really comfortable to wear all day teaching, work with pants or skirts, and they're cute--a cross between dressy Mary Janes and running shoes, hence hybrids. The fabulous soles & heels look like mini-rubber tire treads, which, along with the shoes’ light weight, make them great to wear on snowy/icy sidewalks when you don't want to wear boots. They have a removable orthotic/ liner, and are the first non-Birkenstock shoes I've dared to wear in eight years! They arrived faster than anything I ever ordered online.