Customer Reviews KEEN Presidio

ok, fine after wearing off and on for a time.

Shoe is good but one of the eye hole things popped out already (where the shoe lace comes thru) Too much trouble to return.

The shoe was a little stiff out of the box. They are not very attractive but very comfortable and that's what matters.

Second pair and just like the first. Use for moderate walking off sidewalk

Shoe fit was good and comfortable. However did not like style. Have older pair of same shoe. It has gray contrast on sole and stitching is slightly lighter in color. Think it makes shoe more attractive. Will wait another year and see if style changes a bit. Old pair has been a great shoe for me. Held up very well.

Debated about ordering these but glad I did. Comfortable, true to size, well made, and will be great for winter with heavy socks. Keens fit me well because they’re wide at toe and narrow at heel. These will definitely soften up and form to my foot. They have a good sole and the insert is fine with just enough arch support. Overall they’re keepers.

This is my third pair of Keen shoes and they are very comfortable. There is plenty of toe room and no seams pressing on my feet. I can wear them all day and at the day's end, my feet don't feel tired or hot.

this is a great shoe, well made , good support, sturdy sole. the only drawback is the weight; it is heavy and I am very thin with thin feet, being a low cut shoe and not ankle height, it felt like I was carrying the shoe rather than the other way around. had to return them

Love how these look and most importantly, how they fit/feel! Super cute, but the insole it comes with has zero support (so 4 stars). I ended up replacing them with the insoles from an old pair of Presidios and now they're just right.

Overall size is nice. The toe of the shoe, however, is quite wide.

In my experience, Keen's run half a size small so I ordered an 8 instead of 7-1/2. The fit was perfect and they were comfortable the first time I wore them, which is rare. I wear Presidio's to work (I walk a lot) and the wide toe box means my feet never complain - which is why I continue to buy them. Compared to the three previous Presidio's I've worn, the leather is different - pebbled and non-porous instead of smooth sueded-looking uppers. To me they look cheaper and aren't as stylish. Comfort wins.

This is a very sturdy shoe with great arch support, but unfortunately did not work for me. I have an ankle fusion and the shoe was too difficult to get on for me and hit my ankle in the wrong place, causing discomfort.

I really liked these and wanted to keep them. However the heel fit wasn't good. I'm going to try a different Keen shoe and hope for a better fit

Even though this shoe fit, the tongue gouged my ankle, so I had to return them.

Comfortable, roomy fit. They squeak when walking. Compared them to an older pair. The inside tongue and lining around opening of shoe are leather now versus cloth. Probably will last longer than the cloth lining.

Couldn't tell from pictures online that the toe box area is much larger than I expected; because of that, shoe doesn't look very stylish but I'm sure shoe would be more comfortable for hiking. Because I will not be wearing shoes for hiking and wanted something more stylish, I'm returning them.

At first I thought they might be too small. The tongue hit my instep, but the half size up felt a bit too loose in the heel. I walked around a bit in them and they are a fine fit. I wanted something that felt like a sneaker for city walking but didn't look too much like I forgot to take my running shoes off. So far they suit me fine. BTW....the comments about the toe box being too small did not make sense to me. Maybe my toes are tiny?

The jury is finally in on these Keen Presidio's. As I have a previous pair in the same size, and they fit like a glove from Day One, I couldn’t pinpoint what made me hesitate on these. I wore them for short periods at home but today wore them for longer while visiting a parent. And I am now sure, the left heel is loose. This is odd as that’s my larger foot. I tried all options; pulled laces tighter; added thin cushion; tried different socks; with the Keen inner sole vs without. On my prior pair the ½ size up worked perfectly with orthodics. But these do not. I don’t know if it’s a manufacturing flaw but the left heel is definitely too wide open and even brought on foot discomfort after a couple hours walking around my mother’s carpeted home. These shoes are amazing - if they fit; you can kick a rock or stumble on a concrete step and not injure yourself. The support is great. They are very sturdy and balanced. They STAY tied without double knots. I could walk much further and longer without foot pain. Toe box is superb, they get lots of wiggle room, so feet don’t heat up. Good air circulation. Too bad this pair is a dud!

This looks good and feels good and fits well like my old pair of Presidios. True, as another reviewer pointed out, they do squeak, but so does an old pair of Merrell's that I've worn happily for years. It doesn't bother me. At least with the Presidios, I know the source of the squeak - the tongue - which can presumably be softened. I got the brindle color, that works well as a neutral color, with blacks, greys and browns. I plan to use these as a substitute for athletic shoes, which I don't like. Leather is more versatile all year long.

I love Keens and wear them almost exclusively. I looked for a lace-up last year to replace my old winter Keens, but couldn't find a style that I liked. Renewed my search this year and bought these. I really like them! They look a little bowling-shoe-ish, but in a good way. They are comfortable, with the Keen wide toe box. However, I can't give them 5 stars overall because they seem a tiny bit narrower than usual, but not narrow enough to send them back or deter me from wearing them. Love the Cascade Brown color.

I always wear size 9 M, but this shoe was short in the toe box. I have painful Morton's Neuroma and must have room and support for toes. The shoe is stiff and gave great support to entire foot and I will try a 1/2 size larger. The Brindle/Desert Sun color of this shoe is actually somewhat olive instead of the chocolate milk color in photo.