Customer Reviews Reef Reef Leather Smoothy

Great build quality and look, but the one I got definitely runs small. I bought two other brands in the same size and this one was clearly smaller than the rest when compared. Didn’t fit properly as a result.

Do they even know the dimension of the standard foot? Bought based on some of the positive reviews, should have listened to the negative. Strap is insanely tight (ouch) and feels like it would give a blister after about 10 minutes of wear.

This review is for size 15 only as I'm not seeing any similar complaints about smaller sizes. I have owned Reef flip flops in different styles before and have always been pretty happy with the fit, but this pair is all wrong. It is the right length for my foot overall, but the placement of the toe strap leaves my toes about an inch from the front of the sandal and my heel hanging over the back. This would only fit someone with freakishly long toes. Too bad because they appear to be really well made.

The portion of the straps facing your foot are not leather, but nylon. Not nearly as nice as actual leather flip flops. My older Keen Rockaways (now discontinued) had leather straps. I figured these would be a suitable replacement. No way. Also the footbed (size 8) is just barely the size of my foot. The back of my heel hangs off the back. Stay away from these.

Real good looking and comfortable sandals; however, I've only had them for 3 months now and there's already moderate wear and tear on them from normal use.

These are comfortable and a good looking sandal, but not very durable. The leather began separating from the sole within the first week of wearing them. I've been wearing reefs for years and this is the first time I have had any problems.

These are very comfortable flops but not at all durable. Within 2 weeks of wearing these sandals the leather began separating from the sole. I always assumed Reef was a quality brand but it turns out the flops I bought from Old Navy for a quarter of the price are a higher quality product (although no were as close to comfortable).

Really great looking and comfortable flip-flops! Better looking than this only Dior and Ferragamo! Since I like them a lot, I also wear them a lot and the footbed leather ended up very distressed/damaged in no time (less than three months). I gave them a 2 stars overall because of that. If you want a pair of 5 stars in comfort flip-flops, you should look for heel (air) cushioning.

So I ordered these because they looked great online, but when they arrived they were nothing like the picture. They looked more like canvas than leather. Quickly returned.

These shoes started falling apart the first day I wore them. The leather cover over the rubber soles started peeling off in every direction, and it's only a matter of time before it comes off completely. Horrible quality. I used to love my Reefs -- too bad I'll have to try some Rainbows next.