Customer Reviews Sperry AO 2 Eye

I liked the shoe but the shoes squeaked so badly I just had to return them. I tried wearing them on different floor types but no luck. Squeak...squeak...squeak. No way was I going to wear these in public. I also noticed they were 1/2 size too large.

I love Sperrys, and this is a great and comfortable shoe. But the blue dye from the Navy blue shoe will stain your feet any time they get wet. It has not lessened over time. The dye even soaked through socks. Very disappointing.

Overall this shoe is great in quality. I used to own this exact shoe and it lasted me 6 years. The other day I went to buy the same exact pair because my old ones were falling apart. I bought the same exact size as I had previously and when they came in they were a whole size too small. At first I thought I just had to break them in, but I compared the bottoms of the shoe in size and the ones I had just received were not a true 8

Absolutely love these shoes! Such a classic look and very comfortable, however the soles wore out and it felt like I was walking ice. Had to be conscious of walking as I was afraid I was going to wipe out. Then a huge chunk of the sole came out. It was very upsetting as they were my go-to shoes.

In addition to this shoe not being comfortable, the actual color (I ordered grey) is much lighter than pictured online, almost a soft white-ish. What made the shoe uncomfortable is the leather lace that "weaves" around the outside of the shoe, goes thru an eyelet before it crisscrosses to tie on top of the shoe. Where it goes thru the eyelet, the leather lace rubbed the side of both feet. I am returning the shoes and not reordering any color. I've had this style Sperry in the past and have not had this issue.

I initially ordered this shoe in a 5.5 M. I knew from past experience that this style shoe runs small and narrow for me. I wear a size 5 in dress shoes and sandals. I ordered this style because I liked the all leather shoe in one color and the darker sole, as it looks dressier. I had not seen these in the store, only the bluefish style. I wore leather Sperrys in my school days 30 years ago. The leather of these shoes did not look or feel the same quality. These felt like thinner, cheaper quality leather. I especially did not like the interior insole on these. It only goes halfway and isn't cushioned as well as the bluefish and similar styles, so it is not as comfortable. Even with a 5.5, the left shoe was still too narrow. Also, my heels slipped in them. I returned these and ordered a 5 wide from another vendor. They were too small AND too narrow. There was nothing wide about them, and I could barely get my foot all the way in. I returned those, too. So if I want comfortable Sperrys, I'll have to try one of the more casual styles that are not all leather. I had a pair of black quilted leather shoes some years back that had black patent accents, gold eyelets, black leather laces, black soles, and cushioned insoles. They were so comfortable, looked very sharp, and were better quality. I wish Sperry had stuck with those and the other colors and styles they had then.

I was thinking I might prefer the lighter color but the shoe is just too narrow for my toe box. i returned the shoes today.

This shoe is a little narrow, despite ordering a wide size. It is also too dark a brown compared to what I wanted (the original brown elk color). The tongue and surrounding shoe (where it laces) is much shorter on my foot than the older models of "docksides" that I have worn. Although disappointed, I will reorder this shoe as it is the closest match to the older original versions that I have been able to find.

These shoes are beautiful. Not sure on what planet these are considered wide because they are not! I am hoping they will stretch.

This is a great shoe that I have been looking at for awhile. I finally put some money together and bought a pair but after wearing them I was totally disappointed. They fit narrow, are a little short, and squeak when I walk. Maybe I can get my money back on reselling them and buying another pair the next size up. The shoe itself is great and I love the fact that they are a sturdy leather.

I ordered these shoes and they arrived very quickly. I tried them on, but the shoe was too wide. The size was correct. I returned them due to the width but I plan on ordering the correct size.

Shoe is way to narrow and I have narrow feet

After losing my original pair of sperrys that wEre purchased over 15 years ago (that were still in great condition) this pair of shoes fit and feel grEat. DefinitelEy worth every penny

I bought these shoes in late july of this past year. I wore them quite much, but not enough to be damaged as they currently are. In January, I noticed that my shoes had begain to rip near the throat line. These shoes are fabulous, and I'm discouraged that I can't say the same about the quality.

I love the style and the color but the fit isn't there. I ordered a 9 wide. The nine fits okay but really are not wide at all. They are leather so maybe they would break in and the width would be okay but I didn't take that chance. The other problem is the flat foot bed. There is zero arch support. Just trying them on hurt my feet. So, it was a double whammy... no arch support and too narrow. Had to return them.