Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

J&M Melton cap toe was just the shoe/style I was looking for. Quality made. Still in the process of breaking in - very stiff. Arch not as prominent as I'd like (plantar fasciitis) - requires arch support insert, but the fit accommodates that.

Nice shoes, but very stiff

The shoe tongue is sewn in place one side and putting in the laces for the first time is extremely difficult. The shoe is a very classy and timeless style and fits great.

Nice shoes, looks nice, fairly comfortable after couple weeks of wearing in. The shoelace are not holding the knot for whole day. The heal is too firm to the ground, yet cushioned in the insole.

Very dependable. Been wearing the same Melton shoe for 27 years. Replacing them every 6 months. I wear them every day and sometimes 16 hours a day.

Prefer B width over M.

i like the shoes, but too expensive.

The Melton Cap Toe is an excellent shoe. It runs a little large, by about half a size, however, it fits like a glove otherwise. The only thing I would implore, is to have it made here in the United States.

Great shoe. Wish the bottom wasn't scraped up so easily, but it's very comfortable and worth every penny. Wear it with dark jeans or with a suit. Works either way. Only complaint: could use a more protective bottom. Otherwise, amazing.

Shoe feel slightly too large. Difficult to walk in without concentrating on bending toe area.

Ok

Did not have my size in the shoe I wanted so I had to buy up an extra 100 dollars to get close All my sizes were on back order Don't make 7 and a half in some of the preferred shoes, impossible to order properly on line as eithe rout or not in my size

Beautiful shoe. However, I could not find the right fit and I tried almost every width in my foot length. I may need custom made shoes. My heel is narrow while my toes need extra room.

I use this shoe for dressier occasions.

My Johnson & Murphy shoes are a great addition to my work wardrobe!

Thanks. I was happy with the purchase and service

I originally went to the Johnston and Murphy store to buy my first all leather dress shoes over $100. They measured my feet and I found out that my feet are actually much smaller than I really thought. I measured a 6 1/2 on one foot and almost 7 on the other. So they ordered me a 7 wide since they did not have small sizes in the store. The shoes came in less than a week and they looked very good. However they were way to long for either of my feet so I returned them to the store. They ordered me a 6 1/2 wide and I got them in less than a week. At first they seemed to be ok but after a couple rough days of wearing them they were still to big and actually had something wrong with the soles. Customer service was very nice and I sent them back via UPS for an exchange. I got a 6 wide and they now seem to fit a lot better. They are stiff as heck though and the heels are loud when walking. I have to keep looking back to see if there is anyone behind me with coconut shells. This was the first day of wearing these to work so hopefully will break in. I will come back on here at a later date to update my review.