Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

Great all around classic dress shoe

Great style, perfect fit

Good fit, looks good

The quality and the comfort of these shoes are remarkable. I have worn JM shoes for many years and would not change to another brand.

Love these shoes. Wore them for a couple years and a crack developed in the outer sole. J&M sent me a full replacement at no charge. I'll be a customer for life.

Always top notch

I owned a pair of J&M Oxfords some years ago and loved them. After wearing some less expensive options, it's great to have another pair. Quality materials and craftsmanship makes a difference. It's worth the price!

Great fit and quality workmanship..Thansk will be buying more

Have worn Melton's for years-Great Shoes.

If you are looking for a shoe that is not only comfortable but also durable, this is it. I bought another pair. This is now over 18 years I have been wearing this shoe. I prefer this Melton Cap toe and the Aldrich Ii cap toe.

It is very nice to be able to purchase a well-made, quality size 11 C shoe. With proper care (cleaning, polishing, shoe trees, & foul-weather protection, i.e., boots, etc.) such Johnston Murphy shoes give me years, decades really, of comfort and service.

Very comfortable ad well put together.

These are the most comfortable dress shoes I own, and they look great! It's hard to find new styles that are great looking and have leather soles from J&M nowadays. This is the second pair that I have purchased in 5 years. I love these shoes.

The quality, look and feel of this shoe is A+

Great professional shoe. Please bring back recraftable Ski-Moc Penny Loafers and real stacked leather heel bases.

Another great pair of shoes!

These are the fourth pair of the Melton line of shoes I've owned. They look great, they're built well, and will last years. Thanks for the friends discount!

Look great. Fit my foot like a glove. Comfortable to wear all day. I have no complaints.

I love the quality I got for the relatively low price I paid. They do take some getting used to for the people who are not accustomed to wood soled shoes. But that's the only down side I have for them.