Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

Well built shoe.

Perfect

beautiful shoes but too narrow for the recipient

Shoes were what I expect from a leather dress shoe for formal wear. The only thing that I found different was one side of tongue (each shoe) was sewn to the shoe. It was not a free floating tongue.

great material and quality. Making this review 2 years after the purchase and the Shoes well cared looks like bought 2 months ago. Amazing Brand.

Great looking and comfortable shoe. I did notice threading (white) coming through near the toe in the pair I received.

I have wide feet, so the size 8.5, E width was a little tight. I would recommend 3E. I was also able to go to a size 8. These shoes will last a lifetime, leather soles, uppers and leather lined.

Very comfortable shoe! Highly recommend!

This is a terrific shoe. As expected, the high quality shoe was well made. The shoe is too stiff for me and I prefer a less slippery sole. That’s not JM fault. Just personal preference. I returned this pair and ordered a less expensive lesser quality shoe from Zappos, but different brand. The madden brand fits consistently perfect at 10.5 . I think JM would eventually but I’m not up for breaking them in with fall and ice coming soon.