Customer Reviews KEEN Newport H2

Here's the deal. I wear a size 9.5 in almost every shoe but I these didn't fit at all with a 9.5 -- I mean there was no way I was getting my foot into one of them, period. I ordered a size 10 and only after a determined fight was I able to get my foot past the heel strap. Once my Shrek foot was in there, they fit and felt great, but I was worried that I would eventually end up tearing the sandals apart just putting them on. I tried a size 10.5 and they were a breeze to put on, but then they were too loose for my foot. #SandalFail I ended up returning them and went for a Teva sandal that had an adjustable heel strap. I'm not sure who Keen made these for but apparently not for ogres like me.

Normally I wear a 12W, and I have a pair of Newport 12's that lasted for 2-3 years very well. They fit my foot perfectly. I ordered 12's again, and they were just too tight - couldn't get my foot in them. I went up to a 13 and they seemed okay so I kept them. I've been wearing them for a couple of weeks and the fit just isn't quite right - a little loose in the back. They probably will be okay to wear around town, but not for long walks. Too bad - really like the look.

Make sure you order next size up. They run small. The design has changed since my last pair which makes them harder to slip on. The footbed is harder so they are not quite as comfortable as the last pair was. They appear to be durable. If I hadn't had the previous pair which lasted for 5 years I probably would not be as critical. It is the old "if it ain't broke don't fix it." They tried to improve a great product and messed it up.

I tried on a pair, same style, in a discontinued color, in DSW and, even though they were a FULL size larger than I normally wear, I went home and ordered a pair in Black from Zappos, expecting them to fit just like the ones in the store. But they were STILL too tight. The footbed felt right but the uppers felt like I had an Ace bandage around my foot. I think if I went up another half-size, it might be looser but the rest of the shoe wouldn't feel right. I give up!

I thought these would be lightweight and better for summer, but my foot actually gets much hotter and more uncomfortable in these.

Returned. I was disappointed because the arch/inner sole on one sandal was defected. It has a bump under the the rubber that irritated the side of my foot.

These do seem to run about 1/2 size small. They are pretty comfortable but do rub my pinky toes a little. I don't get a blister or any soreness, but I do feel it happening. I ordered these to use as a summer shoe, but they just don't let my feet breathe enough. The closed to area is great for protection, but it really makes your feet hot. I had hear that mentioned in other reviews, but was really surprised on how hot my feet stay with these on. I also wish they offered better colors. I got the Brindle/Orion Blue. It's basically a light gray color. I like it but wish they offered something like a brown. Overall I like them but not as much as I thought I would.

I wanted to like these shoes, but the fit just was not right. They were tight in the back put loose in the front. Also, the heel of the sole on one of the shoes was poorly manufactured. It had a small piece of plastic protruding from the seam.

These didnt fit my feet well. They kept slipping despite being tightened and my heel would hang off the back. That being said, they are well made.

I love Keen sandals, this is my second pair (the first one lasted 2 years). Overall, another good sandal but I do have a weird complaint. These things stink! I do not normally have stinky feet. My previous Newports were leather and never got funky. These things melt down after just a few minutes of wearing them and end up smelling horrible. My wife was the first to notice, now I have become very aware of their smell. I wonder if it has something to do with either the new footbed or the new anti-bacterial treatment that they use on it. I hope to find a solution to the stink, but, for now, it is the only thing keeping me from giving these a 5 star rating.

It's a great alternative for summer wear. But it took forever to break in. Finally after a month of weekend. I can wear them without pain. Still not the most comfortable shoe.

Pros: Nice design, durable, light weight, waterproof. Cons: No cushion (it kills my fore foot and heel when I walk with it for some distances.) Depend on my experience, Teva sandals provide much better cushion.

I have an older pair and I am a little concerned that some of the stitches are popping off in the rear section of the sandal. The other pair is well over 3 years old and while the traction is a little rubbed out I think they are constructed better. The fit is the same I am just concerned about durability.

Very comfy and I like them, however, I'm disappointed in the construction. The stitching has come apart in the same place on both shoes, on both sides of the foot where the heel strap connects to the sole.

The shoes are well made, but the comfort level is not as good as I had expected. I have owned Teva sandals which I wore till they came apart. The Teva's were extremely comfortable and the fit was perfect. The Keen tends to bind the little toe on each foot somewhat decreasing the comfort level.

I love Keen shoes! I have been an a loyal Keen-shoe wearer for at least 8 years. They are the only shoes that I can wear on my daily commute (especially the Paulina Mary Jane), to work, in a river, or while hiking. I honestly don't know what other shoe I would even like to wear that has proven itself so versatile, interesting, and durable.This is why I am so saddened to have to write this review. Keen is not branching out for women above size 11 shoes so I generally have to wear a man's shoe (boring colors and styles). To my dismay, after only 3 months of wear, my new Newport H2 shoe began to fray on the inner ankle.

Quality if Keen Newport is suspect - I like my Keen Newport H2, but I will not be "showing them off to my friends". Why? They are practical and great for hiking, but the quality of the finish is not there. Specifically, the soles are "multi color", but that only means it is a base rubber color with a second color painted on. The very first time they got wet, the finish came off in blotchy patterns on the sides of the soles and the toe. I would not buy these shoes if you are looking for something that is durable and stays nice looking.

Disappointed in style and comfort compared to other Keens. Chose to return these. Very happy with Zappos customer svc. It's simply the best.