Customer Reviews Naot Kayla

Really cute sandles but they run really wide.

They are somewhat wide and the back strap was too wide to keep my foot stable. They are a comfortable shoe normally; I have had two pairs prior to these. Ashley and another, the name of which I don't recall. I really liked both of them and wore them often.

Kayla sandals are so cute and really comfortable. They have received the American Podiatric Association Seal. Unfortunately, the second strap was to big for me. I took them to the my shoe repair and he cut the sandal open and the strap, glued it back together and I have a new pair of sandals. I'm a big believer of fixing shoes, and clothes to make them fit me.

I think I received a miss marked shoe. When comparing Kayla to another Naot sandal, this Kayla was a almost an inch shorter in length….I took a photo but the app review field isn’t functional on my android phone

these are very comfortable but they are a much lighter purple than pictured. i am going to return them because they are a lavender tint silver color and i wanted darker.

My first reaction to the Brick Red was wow what a perfect color! Then I noticed a small black smudge on the strap. OK maybe it won't show. Then I tried them on. One foot was decidedly loose across the top two straps. This is my second pair of Kaylas so I know how they are supposed to fit. Then I thought ok I will try another pair but sooo disappointed they were out of my size. I could work with the smudge but the different feel of the two feet were more than I could deal with. So back they go.

I wish there were a category for returns that said, "too big AND too small". The sole seems narrower than other Naots I own and love; my toes hang over the edges. However, the straps on this style are far too wide and there's a significant gap around my foot. So, I'd be flopping all around in them and probably break an ankle. 'So sorry, they have to go back! (They ARE beautiful, and Naots are always great shoes! 'Just weird sizing in this one.)

I have narrow feet and the straps in the front are quite loose. I tried wearing the shoes but am afraid the leather will stretch and no longer support my foot. So I'm sending them back before trying to break them in.

I did not like the color. I had expected a silver color and it was really just gray.

Sadly had to return because this shoe runs narrow. I have been a medium width my whole life and the shoe bed runs narrow.

I really, really wanted this shoe however the velcro straps just didn't work for me. The straps are too long for narrow feet. The strap placement seemed off as well. This seems to be one of the narrower Naot sandals but the straps are just too long for my thin feet. I normally wear size 9N or 9.5N but I had to go up to a 10 and the fit still seemed almost too short and too wide. Additionally, I need at least moderate arch support. I really like the light weight of the sandals and the Navy blue color. It is getting more and more difficult to find good fitting narrow or "narrower" sandals (and shoes). Thank goodness Zappos offers more variety than anyone else and has convenient returns. I'll keep trying!!!

These Kayla straps across your foot are MUCH LONGER or Wider than all my other Kayla sandals. I'm guessing at least half an inch, so disappointed I have to return, I thought sure ordering these was a sure bet! I comparted these to my other Kaylas and there is a significant difference.

Very cute shoes and comfortable however the sizing is not correct. Go a 1/2 size up for sure!

I have had a pair of Kaylas for several years and they've served me well. The only reason I gave the new pair an overall rating of three stars is that the straps across the toes are way too tight. Alas, I must return them.

I agree with the other reviewer who said the Naot Kayla's are inconsistent in sizing. At her recommendation, I've ordered different sizes and colors. In general, it seems the Naot footbeds run short and slightly narrow and the straps are disproportionately sized. The straps in the pair in Oily Dune were really long, such that only half the velcro closure could be used; the rest was hanging unused. If the sandals stretched, which many reviewers have said they do, I wouldn't have been able to fasten them. The Stone Nubuck, which is a nice, neutral color, had a similar problem. Additionally, they came with an oily stain. Since they weren't in the original manufacturers box, I assume the stain is from whoever returned them before me. The Buffalo Leather pair fit the best, and the straps are correctly sized, but the sandals are quite dark. With the wider straps, the shoe doesn't look very feminine. If you can find the right size/color combination, and like a sandal with wide straps, this could be a comfortable shoe for very casual wear. Unfortunately for me, they all have to go back.

I have narrow feet 6-6.5. The front 2 straps were already much looser on this shoe than on the same brand / same style that I’ve owned and worn every summer for 15 years. Wanted to own this color, to go with sundresses, but couldn’t make it work.

The shoe seemed small. I wear an 8M, sometimes 8.5M, and my toes were practically off the end of the shoe. The oily dune color looks like a nice tan in the photo, but it's really yellow-ish. The leather finish is very natural and will easily scuff and scratch. Another reviewer said the sizing is inconsistent from shoe to shoe, so I will reorder in both 39 and 40 in the buffalo.

Back strap was too loose. My medium width foot kept sliding forward, so my foot hung off the front. Have another model of Naot that fits perfectly. Also, a little too flat and open for the office. I am returning.

I returned these as I didn't trust that the front strap wouldn't stretch out and allow my toes to slide too far forward, and with no way to adjust the front for that...I was also not thrilled with the color I had, Crinkly Steel Leather, which looked more generically gray than metal. I guess I expected a more metallic look and it wasn't. I liked the shoes, but at the price, not enough to keep and have them last a long time. I'm going with a style that has a toe adjustment.

True to other customer reviews, this shoe's sizing is just 'off.' It runs 1/2 size small. It is a cute shoe, and is nice quality, aside from the sizing issue.

I was disappointed in the fit. I usually wear a size 11 or a 42. I felt tike these shoes were a size and a half too small.

These feel pretty good on. I have a foot that is on the wide side of average and these feel a bit narrow. I could live with that. However, I was not crazy about the black color on the base of the shoe with the light brown color. I really wanted something in more of a cork color. The velcro is really strong which I liked. Sadly, these are going back as I needed to be 100% in love with them to justify the high price.

I've bought this style in a different color before and loved it. The black matte was both shorter and much narrower. I'm pretty disappointed. Going up a size will not solve the narrower situation. Enjoy if you have slim feet!

Not really "true to size" anymore. :( I have owned this shoe for years because I have terrible feet that have endured surgeries and still have issues. This shoe has been my go-to for exploring cobblestone streets in Europe or tracking local mileage around town. I thought I would just go online and re-order my same-old black Naots but they were oddly loose. I have narrow heels to start and always have to velcro them tight but the leather over the front of my foot was also just too big. I was extremely disappointed. I don't know if it was a fluke pair or a new production flaw but I am leaving soon to travel and cannot take the chance. I returned them.

Super cute. But a tad small running and found straps over foot to be too tight.