Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Grayson

I have been a long time Allen Edmonds customer, Love everything I purchase from them. I usually buy during sales. These shoes look and fit great.

I wanted the Acheson. Apparently, they no longer make it. The Grayson has a higher vamp. The very thing I didn't want. Quality made shoe, but not for me. I took a chance and wasted my money. A lot of money.

I have owned Allen Edmonds shoes for 52 years. There is nothing from any manufacturer that can compare with these shoes. Their quality, size options, distinctive style has always been their hallmark and always will be. Other shoe makers do not have the recrafting capabilities. Here they don't just re-sole your shoes, they remake them from the ground up. Love my Allen Edmonds shoes!

This is a classic Allen Edmonds shoe; as soon as you put it on, you can tell it's going to fit and feel great. The same type of quality and feel as a more substantial, lace-up AE dress shoe.

I have many Allen Edmunds and some go back to the old ownership. The quality in the older shoes is very good. The present shoes and styles are okay but not the excellency of the past. I can live with that because i have so many from the old ownership and if needed can have them repaired by Allen Edmonds. Bill Clancy

I have 3 pairs of the Grayson and all still look good dressed up or dressed down. Why not update the classic CHELSEA model it was a one of your best! thank you

Do I like AE Grayson shoes? I have eleven pairs and rarely have worn anything else in last 20+ years. Exceptions for rain/mud or heavy outdoor use (boots). ps: Bring back cordovan color in std Graysons!!!

I love this shoe so much I have it in multiple colors. Both pairs fit like gloves on my feet and worn 10 hours at work still feel comfortable as if I'm barefoot on a shag rug. Even though I thought you had to be 50+ to have tassels on your shoes I bought my first pair at 32 and the simplistic yet timeless style is unmatched. Besides the Shreveport it's my favorite AE shoe to wear on any occasion besides the gym.

A great shoe I'd highly recommend!! I've owned three pair and they have performed admirably!!

This is a great looking shoe that feels like you're walking on steel plates, noisily clanking along. There's not a scintilla of padding in the footbed! Compare that to any other (better) dress shoes in your closet. When you counter this with a thin Spenco pad, your feet get pressed up against the shoe's tongue - trading one misery for another. I regret making this purchase.

Subpar quality to say the least. The tassels are flimsy and not as shown in the photo. They make the entire shoe look cheap. The quality of Allen Edmonds shoes has gone significantly down. This will be my last pair of Allen Edmonds shoes. If you want high quality tassel loafers look elsewhere.

I own (2) pairs of AE Grayson model: (1) Oxblood & (1) Black. The last of the new pair of Grayson Oxblood's received were .25" longer & .25" wider in the heel counter. Hence, they were too big for my feet. My heel readily slipped out when walking. My existing pairs which are 10-15 years old respectfully & religiously maintained with AE shoe trees fit tighter than this new pair. My only surmise is that the last has changed significantly. This new pair was returned.

This shoe in black is a dull black not shinny which is not what I expected. otherwise it is of good quality

Allen Edmunds products never disappoint. The shoes and belt I recently purchased were a perfect fit! The beauty and quality of Allen Edmunds leather goods are superb. I have been purchasing AE shoes for my husband for over twenty years and they have remained of the highest quality and fit. I plan to continue purchasing from AE in the future.

My Dad wear them for 60 years. If I ever get to Wisconsin I would like to visit the factory. Thank you for making a GREAT shoe.

It's all about the quality of your shoes that means the most to me and I love the style. This product does not let you down.

Overpriced, dull matte finish, not comfortable, a poor dress loader

I wanted this shoes for a few years to replace a similar pair I had worn for years. These are a great replacement. look good and feel good. Great level of finish.

Love the classic style of shoes, extremely easy to polish to a brilliant shine and a great fit.

The loafer quality was less than I would expect. In fact a cheaper look than any Allen Edmonds shoe I've ever purchased.

Fantastic shoe that can be worn for work or even casual. At first I thought it was to big but after talking to a sales rep it broke in perfectly as it molded to my 8.5 D foot.

Purchased these loafers as have been very satisfied with other Allen Edmunds shoes I have owned. Only problem I have with the shoes is that they are a bit too wide for me in the heel. Will have to see a local shoe repair shop to rectify. Otherwise am extremely happy with these loafers.

I have a wide foot and a high instep, so I was a bit concerned about getting a slipon, but I liked the way the Grayson looked in the pictures. I couldn't be more pleased. They fit perfectly and look and feel great. They also smell like new leather, which I love. Keep them in the bags with cedar shoe trees in when they're not on your feet. You'll love them!

Allen Edmonds has outstanding quality and exceptional value. Meticulous attention to detail, style and comfort.

I ordered the 11 2e. I needed to order the 11 e. I am returning the shoe, for right size. It is a beautiful and well made shoe.