Customer Reviews Florsheim Edgar Cap Toe Oxford

Going back, it's marked wide (3E) but feels very tight even when laced very loose. I have tried 2 other pairs of wide dress shoes and know what wide should feel like...

I have wide feet, and the 3E felt very narrow. I would say it is wide at best probably narrower then that. If you have wide feet I would not recommend these shoes.

Surprised that many reviewers say they are comfortable; wore them once for a long day of work so far, and by night the heels were rubbing and causing a lot of pain. Unfortunately cannot return them because I wore them. They look good and seem comfortable at first, but after a while it almost became unbearable with the heels.

Cannot wear this shoe. Does not fit well. Heel areas rub badly and cramps toes. Would not break in. Should have returned. Looks good but feels terrible.

I have worn these shoes for two years but have put new heels and a half-sole on. The shoes still wear great and surprisingly they look close to new. They have held their shape wonderfully. However, I do keep shoe trees in them and rotate them with another pair of shoes every other day. I do wish, however, they were manufactured in a 4E width. That would make me very happy. Zappos has been fantastic to work with. I have only had to return one pair of shoes in all these years and they were wonderful to work with. I really like the free shipping and almost instant delivery!

A great classic black dress shoe. Fits and feels comfortable right out of the box. I haven't gotten to wear them for extended periods of time yet but so far I am very pleased with the purchase!

I really wanted to keep these shoes but they just did not work. They are great looking and would make a nice pair of dress or work shoes but they are very narrow in the D width. The soles are very slick, though I know they will be better after they are broken in. Tried the W(EEE) width but it was much too loose. I guess it was not meant to be. Zappos was excellent and gave no problems with the exchange.

I have had Florsheim shoes in the past and had thought that they were a quality shoe, so I ordered them without hesitation. This pair will be the last ones I will ever buy. They are surprisingly disappointing. Specifically, they are unconformable to wear. Whatever they put in the bottom of the shoe for cushioning is poor and clumps up and mats between the toes forming uncomfortable ridges almost the first day of wearing. I purchased black leather and the shoes have kind of a satin finish that is difficult to polish and shine. Perhaps the worst is the squeaking. I have never had a pair of shoes that made so much noise, the right worse than the left, forming a kind of squeaky cadence as you walk.