Customer Reviews Florsheim Noble Plain Toe Oxford

I've been walking on Florsheim Noble for the last 10+ years. I am very disappointed with the latest pair. It is not the same. The laces are now skinny and you're forced to bend your ass over after every walk. They come off too easily. After a month of wearing, the shoes are still stiff and hard. Sadly, I'm going to have to start looking for a new brand.

A real disappointment - I've given up on these shoes because one started to squeak after a year or so and kept getting worse. It's gotten so bad that I can't really wear them. Otherwise, they've been great. They're a great combination of comfort and good looks, which is hard to find in a dressy shoe. I've worn them quite a bit and they're not showing any serious signs of wear. There's lots of life left on the soles. So, it's really disappointing - the kind of thing you might expect from shoes that cast a lot less.

Good, but... This is one of the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned. However, the quality of the assembly of the shoe was absolutely terrible. The insole in both shoes pulled out when I took my shoes off the first time I wore them. The felt covering on the rubber insoles also came loose. I had to superglue the felt back on (what a chore) and then superglue the insole back into the base shoe. I could have returned them, but the fix was easier than the hassle of returning the shoe. I have never seen such bad quality from Florsheim.

Be prepared to buy some shoe polish... Overall, this shoe is quite comfortable. However, in a very short period of time, less than a month, the paint on the bottom part of the shoe will start to peel. You'll probably end up sanding the rest of the paint off to maintain a smooth appearance. Then you'll need to get some black shoe polish to re-paint it. Additionally, there is a flaw in the sole of the shoe which causes them to start squeaking after about a month. Two or more months, and the squeaking gets louder and louder. I don't know what it it, but it's really annoying. If you can deal with the squeaking and applying a good polish, the shoes will suffice.

Florsheim Noble - I never thought I'd be wearing Florsheims, but their Comfortech line is obviously designed to compete with shoes from Clark's, Rockport, Ecco, etc. These are great looking shoes, with great comfort. They are dressy enough to wear with a business suit, and casual enough to wear with chinos or jeans.

I really want to like these shoes, they have so much going for them! But ultimately, it’s the fit and function that determine how good a shoe is, and this one, unfortunately, just doesn’t work well with my feet. The good: These are high quality footwear. The seams are constructed perfectly, the materials are top notch and the aesthetics timeless. The craftsmanship is just beautiful and they are comfortable right out of the box. They seem to fit a vast majority of wearers quite nicely. The not so good: The design of the shoe includes a support piece that my foot is not used to, which does not work well with my gait and causes pain. On a regular dress shoe, the heel and the foot pad sections are separated with an open space. For example, wearing regular shoes, when standing up, it is possible to slide a pencil under your shoe on one side and have it come out the other side. The Nobles do not allow that. The area which is typically open is covered by a two inch wedge that connects the heel to the foot pad. This adds rigidity to the shoe, since the bottom of the shoe is always connected to the ground. Look at the 3rd picture from the top and see the lighter colored middle section of the bottom of the shoe. It’s hard to tell from the picture, but that entire section makes contact with the ground when you walk. If you look at the 4th picture, zoom in on the heel portion and you’ll see it a little bit better. It would be nice to have a ground-level side view so this feature can be better appreciated. For many (or most, based on the reviews), this function adds comfort. For me, however, this creates a pressure point where none exists in all my other dress shoes. Combine that with my 10-2 feet (the natural position of my feet point out a little bit), and with my gait that wears the outside back portion of my shoes quicker, that pressure point starts to become noticeable, then warm, then by the end of the day painful. If I wear the shoes back to back days, by the third day the foot hurts so much I can barely walk. Clearly my experience is the rare exception. But if your feet at all sound like mine vis a vis position and gait, you may want to pay special attention to the fit, and wear them in your home carpet a little longer than usual to see if that pressure point starts showing up. If it does, you may consider a different shoe.

Bought these shoes based on the idea that they provided great support if you're wearing them often. I'm on my feet all day for my job and was very disappointed in the fit of the shoes. They grip very tightly around the throat line and they did not loosen up. Soft leather and great look though. Will unfortunately have to sell or donate to Goodwill since I can't wear the shoes comfortably.

Looks good, feels lousy - My husband bought a pair of Florsheim comfortech shoes about two years ago. They wore like iron and were very comfortable. They finally wore out and we ordered this pair to replace them. While they did fit as per length and width, they were very uncomfortable as there is almost no padding in the shoe anywhere except at the heel. I compared them to his old shoes and you can see they are now made very cheaply with a thin fabric lining. The old pair had a full padded lining stitched into the shoe. It's sad to see a brand like Florsheim joining all the other companies cheapening their product.

Shoes look OLD after one year - I got this shoe as a gift for my Dad a year ago. After only about 10 uses, the leather started to look very worn in certain spots. They look like they have been through 5 years of constant wear – which they have not! Not sure if Florsheim's quality has diminished overall or if it was just this particular model – but it is terrible!!! And these were not cheap shoes!

Not the best shoe I've ever had... Maybe it's because I am used to better fitting shoes and more casual leather shoes, but these shoes were a waste of money by comparison to other shoes I've owned. They cost the same as shoes that feel 10 times better. They don't have much cushioning, the fabric on the insoles started coming loose within a few weeks of wearing them, and the color comes off easily. I had to get down on a carpeted floor to briefly do something with a PC and now have little color on the tips of the shoes. These aren't the worst shoes I've owned I'm sure, but certainly not one of the best. I give them a 2 because of that.

I am on my feet all day long. I have had two pair of the 17080-05 style shoe. They fit and feel great and I try to take good care of them. My big problem with the shoe is that the side splits out by the sole (twice). I like these shoes but I do not think I can get another pair.

New sole design - A narrow ramp exist on the sole of the shoe between the heel that blends into the flat front part of the shoe. If you some how step on a curb or stair on angle the shoe will roll. Make sure you understand the odd shape of the sole.