Customer Reviews Florsheim Berkley Penny Loafers

Sizing issues

RETURNED BECAUSE SIZE IS TOO SMALL

Despite a price reduction, the shoe is not worth more than $30.00. The construction is shoddy. I expect the beef roll stitching to split. Very disappointed in the lowering of Florsheim standards.

The front upper wore out almost right away. I wore it normally in the summer as I have my penny loafers for years. I have a normal gait. Bought new in Summer, and within FIVE wear days (and I work in a carpeted office, but walk four blocks to work)the front upper wore out on the right shoe evidently because this shoe's front bulged out over the sole of the shoe in front and scraped the pavement with every step. I had to discard the shoe virtually brand new!This happened once before, years ago with a Dexter. I am giving Florsheim one more chance with this penny loafer purchase this time, since they had a good track record before this particular shoe was such a waste of money and disappointment.

These shoes make a loud noise when I walk, like many other Florsheim shoes I have purchased. I am going to return these shoes and never buy Florsheim shoes again.

The shoes are without a doubt mislabeled and too big. Now I have to pay to send them back and hopefully the right size shoes will be returned to me. Not pleased.

These shoes last me 3 months after purchase. I work in a school and I wore 2 holes in my shoes on each foot. I returned the shoes and got another pair hoping it would be different and it was not... I now have another hole in one of the shoes and now have to return them again. I would not recommend these shoes to anyone! Walmart shoes last longer!

I order the first pair and had to return to due the size. I ordered a second pair and also had to return. I finaaly went to the retail store in New York City and purchased a proper fitting pair.

I have worn this shoe in burgundy and black for apx 25 yrs. Last two orders did not fit as they have in the past. The shoe is being made differently-lighter weight, stitching of soles is different, fit is more narrow than in past--in past it didn't need breaking in--it was comfortable from day one. I have 2 old pr that were made correctly if you want to compare. Contact me if you want more info ([@]). I would like to see you bring this show back to Florshime standard of the past. I plan to write your Chairman. I hope I can find a shoe as good as the Berkley you made in the past.

I have always bought Florsheim shoes before,and got great wear and durability, put now there is almost no leather in the product and they look like a cheap pair of vinyl shoes. Use more leather to rebuild your quality and name.

Was unable to keep these as they were too small - purchased from USA and paid in US$ with shipping total [$].Had to return shoes to Montreal (I live in Calgary, Canada)and paid $24.79.Just received notice that the refund for this purchase will be $120.00 US$. My issue is - I paid $60.00 shipping then $24.79 again to ship back. I am now down $84.79 - all because your shoes were made incorrectly. This is disappointing and unacceptable(the Berkley shoes were $95.00). To date, I have purchased 2 pair of shoes from you - same size and width with no problem. I feel your company is not fair. In other words - I paid $84.79 and I have absolutely nothing!

I have been wearing Florsheim shoes for most of my adult life (8 1/2D). My first time online purchase of 8 1/2D did not go well...Too narrow had to return for E's???????????? Lets see what happens? I would recommend but maybe not online?

Accustomed to wearing Florsheim Royal Imperial penny loafers. Made in the USA. These are a very poor substitue. Even shoes previously made in Mexico were better than this Asian product. Hard, stiff and very uncomfortable. When it comes to shoes and comfort the price should never be an object.