Customer Reviews Stacy Adams Madison Boot

My review of Stacy Adams Madisons. For those of us who like a boot type shoe, I would highly recommend the Stacy Adams madison boots. This is a very comfortable, well made dress boot for that person who like for their foot to look good and feel good at the same time. This no doubt is the boot for you.

Love this boot! I have problems with my feet, but wanted a dressy boot to wear to my son's wedding. With some trepidation, I bought this boot online because I liked the look of it. The only problem now is that I want a pair in every color! These boots were comfortable from the moment I put them on, I'd recommend them to anyone who wants a great look and comfort too.

The Madison Boot by Stacy Adams's - I have always liked the looks of this type of shoe since I was a little kid, I would see the older ones wearing them and they looked so dignified. I've had these for a month now and they have worked out great. The only complaint was from my wife concerning the amount of creaking (noise) they made while I was breaking them in. Leather does that, and there is alot of it in these boots. They are a very comfortable boot to wear even though they do not have all of the fancy padding that some of my other shoes have. As far as being able to wear them out in any type of weather this has not been a problem. We are now into the rainy season here, and my feet have stayed dry. I've been waiting to finish breaking them in before I apply any water repellant and so far so good. I would have no qualms in recommending this shoe to anyone.

Best dress boot around - I have seen and talked to others who have worn this boot for years. Until recently I've always worn the Madison shoes which are superior. Then I ordered some boots and have been more than satisfied. I am ready to buy more and recently convinced my friend to buy a couple of pairs. They are simply the best at any cost. The comfort? OUT OF THIS WORLD. NO DOUBT ABOUT IT!

Stacy Adams Madison Boot - First pair of Stacy Adams I have bought but it won't be the last. I was very pleased with the boots from the day I opened the box. I've worn high top shoes for many years but have found it hard to replace my old favorites, new ones are hard to find in the malls. Zappos shipped in exactly the time they said they would. The Madison is a well made boot, extremely comfortable and great looking. Thanks.

I LOVE these boots and I'm a white guy. I've had these before a number of times, but the shoe store in Chicago where I bought them closed down a few years ago and I could not find them any more (also had a Gray pair). I don't mind paying $100 because they are GREAT!

These boots were made for walkin' Since the mid 1960's I have worn lace-up boots. For about twenty-five years I have had my boots hand made by a company in Spokane, Washington. Lately, while having two pairs of my boots rebuilt by the Spokane-based company, I bought two pairs of Madison's by Stacy Adams. These boots look and feel terrific. As long as Stacy Adams continues to make these boots, these will be my boots of choice. I positively love these boots. By the by, I wear a 9.5 "B" width. Although these are called a "D" width, they fit my very well, which makes me believe that they do run a bit narrow and will fit those who have narrow feet. Really a top knotch boot for the money. Great looks and great value!

A Leader Always Leads. As a kid growing up I used to see classy older gentlement wearing the Madison and I made a promise that would be the shoe of my choice. I have a closet full of shoes and boots, but I have been wearing the Stacy Adams Madison for over twenty years and still own the first pair that I purchased. I wear the oxford, the slip on and the boots in brown and black. The quality and workmanship is unmatched in the price point. I store the footwear on cedar shoe trees and find that this keeps the shape and the new shoe look for years and extends the life of the shoe significantly. You can't go wrong with the Stacy Adams Madison, it can take you from the out house to the white house in true style.

Buying another pair! These boots are fantastic. I just received the pair of black boots that I ordered and am in the process of ordering a pair of brown. They are extremely comfortable and made in a traditional style that's hard to find.

Known comfort. I've been wearing this shoe for over 20 years and have gotten very use to the look of the boot and the white stitch. The look speaks for itself.

Wunnerful Wunnerful If you are looking for a good shoe, actually boot in this case, this is it! I have wide big feet, and this is the only dress boot I can find, fortunately, It is wonderful. Since I also have bad ankles, the extra support provided by the lace up is just what the doctor ordered. I don't think I will ever go back to a low cut show again. I am also a rather nostalgic 20 year old, so this fits my personality rather well. I would recommend this one to anyone that Has a hard time finding good shoes.

I really like these shoes. If you are going to order get a full size smaller than your usual size and order a wide. I was skeptical about other reviews on the sizing but I followed the advice and ordered following these rules and it was a perfect fit. The leather is a bit too shiny for me but with wear it will become perfect. I was surprised at the comfort. No matter how far I walked my feet never ached. Some might complain that the top of the boot rubs or bites into their ankles but the solution is to lace them up leaving two hooks empty at the top. If the shoe slips around than you need a smaller size anyways. Overall i may order another pair later on in a different color to match to any outfit.

I just bought and received my second pair of Madison boots. But first let me review the durability and quality of my first pair. My first pair of Stacys are over 3 years old and have been through a lot. When I first got them, they were extremely comfy but that was before I realized that these shoes run large. Still, I wore them! The breaking in time for me was roughly a week of daily wear and after that they were the most comfortable shoes ever. My original Stacys were/are my everyday shoes. Wore them through rain, snow, desert heat, flood, blood (don't ask me how), vomit (parties!), alcohol (more parties!) and they even survived being dumped into a backyard pool! Of course I was attached to them. My first pair took a year and a half to wear through the original sole. Durable for such a thin sole when all things are considered! When I got them resoled, I asked the cobbler to make the soles thicker and replace the leather/rubber heel with a full rubber heel for added comfort and durability. After these modification the shoes are still going on strong after daily wearing for a year and a half (nearing two years) since the resole job. The uppers are thin and are built with glove leather which is the reason why are thin. Yes, they do get creases and the leather doesn't do entirely well against rough/textured objects. Excessive (over a year or more) wear will cause cracks, but if you are one of those type people that enjoy that worn look (like myself) then it isn't a problem. I ordered my second pair a size smaller. In a nutshell they run narrow. Quality seems the same, but we will see. Tips: baby powder or talcum powder on the tongue and leather touching areas greatly reduce or even entirely get rid of the squeaking. Hand bending and massaging the leather before wear loosen the leather. I also recommend to wear the them loose for a bit to aid in faster break in time. Also, better shoe laces.

I purchased these shoes for purely nostalgic reasons, i.e. they resemble shoes that my grandfather wore and shoes that were sold in my family's general store when I was a child in the 1940's. I selected the 9 because an 8.5 E was not available. I am satisfied with my purchase.

Love the look and style, and actually pretty comfortable too. The break in time is pretty standard, mine are still a little creaky even after a month or so of weekly wear and oiling, and the leather is a bit thin to really put them to heavy use (already have a spot on the outside of my foot where my toe created a crack on the outside). Other than the quality of the leather these are great, will definitely remain my favorite (and right now only) black shoes!

This unique looking shoe looks like it is painted over. Nice design, thin and supple, but with a high gloss like a patent-leather. It is hard to see how glossy this shoe really is on the pictures.

I've wanted a pair of these since the early 1980's. I normally take a 10.5 D. Sometimes a 10. After four previous size orders, I ended up with a 9E. Never needed an E width before and haven't worn a 9 in decades. These are made in India which was a negative for me but quality is high. They make a more expensive variation of this boot that, I suspect is made in the USA. Very cool in a retro kinda way.

Classy boot - I have had the Madison Boot for about a month and love it. It's a very sleek, elegant shoe that is more comfortable than I thought it would be. I bought it in an 11, though I typically wear 10 1/2 (which probably would have worked fine). My only small complaint is that the leather is a bit thin and the shoe strings are not for dress shoes. Otherwise, I recommend this classy boot to anyone who likes super-sharp styles.

Excellent costume shoe - The Madison is an excellent shoe for costuming period shows. As a costume designer I have used them often. Your service was excellent and as was your price, unfortunately they did not fit the actor well so we had to go to an alternative shoe. Thank you for your excellent service.

Stacy Adam's Madison Boots - Very comfortable to wear even on the first day. The leather squeaks and the contrasting stiching around the sole makes them look cheesy, at least on the brown model. Cheap shoelaces.