Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Harrington II

I’ve owned two other pairs of these shoes. They are workhorses!

The shoes are good and this is the 3rd pair I have had in 2 years or less. The real issue is that Dr. Scholl's uses cheap inferior shoe laces. They start to fray in 2-3 weeks and will break by 6 weeks. I walk 6+ miles a day. This is why I get less than a year's use of the shoes. But I find this to be true of any brand shoe. I am hard on shoes! The non slip soles are good. I have tried Clarks, Timberline and others. All wear out in about the same time for me. But the Dr. Scholl's shoes are 1/2 the price of Clarks. As of now, when I wear this pair out (Spring 2019) I will buy another pair of these same shoes. Zappos service is the best.

Almost kept these but sketchers one. These were not as dark, Herrington 2 brown, and more burgundy than brown. But didn’t have a steal toe. Will look at this brand again for sure.

I've owned a couple pairs. Great work shoe, but not something I'd wear out. It's good for long hours on your feet and some walking. I've never felt like the soles didn't provide reasonable traction even in winter weather. All told a solid shoe, though the insoles do seem to wear out fairly quickly.

I'd rather have give it 4.5 stars out of 5, but it won't let me. These are good shoes, especially for the price. I have wide feet, and high arch on one foot, so a lot of shoes don't fit well and cause severe discomfort. And I've been through a ton of different 3rd party sole inserts as well. These fit really well and are quite comfortable to walk and stand in. The inserts that came with it are adequate to above average, as I hoped being Dr. Scholl's brand shoes. I got these in black at the same time I got some wide Timberland Pro oxfords in brown; I wear brown about 5 times as frequently as black so I didn't want to spend as much on the black shoes. I'll be honest, as much as I love the Timberland Pros, the half-the-price Dr. Scholl's may even be slightly more comfortable. Their main downside to me is that they don't look particularly fashionable. They don't look bad, just kind of average.

Laces showing bad wear after 5 days! Shoes do fit well, good traction sole. I think the laces are supplied by an outside supplier to the manufacturer. Lower quality laces. Shoes OK.

These shoes were not provide the comfort I expect from Dr. Scholls.

Style is great, they are comfortable and fit very well. However, the downside is the non-slip soles wear down rather quickly, at least in my line of work as a bartender in a restaurant. In 6 months the non-slip has completely worn-down and make them impossible to wear in my restaurant without risk of slipping and falling. Would not recommend for environments where a non-slip shoe is essential, they will not hold up. That said, still a fan of the shoe overall and I'm sure in other workplaces would be fine.