Customer Reviews Dr. Scholl's Harrington II

I have pirchased these shoes many times over the years. I wear them all the time while teaching school, at home, and anywhere that I am working outside. Things that I like are the stitched soles, the nonmarking aspect, the real leather, and the blue inserts. I do find that the laces wear out after about a year. Also the cushioning around the ankle peels and looks terrible...this should be remedied. The leather shoe itself polishes up nice for special events. On my most recent pair, my left shoe lower sole has begun to separate from the inner sole. Maybe not enough glue?? Or just because I bend this shoe more as I squat while working?? I still thing these are the best shoes that I have had for comfort. I have previously been a shoe repairman and when my sisters bought me my first pair of Dr. Scholl's shoes, I just kept on buying more of the same as the years went by.

Once they're broken in and you've replaced the insoles they come with, these nonslips are great! Was sorely disappointed by the default insoles, given that these are work shoes.

These shoes scuff. My last pair (similar but not Harrington II did not scuff. When putting the shoes on the tongue wants to crimp and must be pulled straight something else the last pair did not due. I am very happy with the shoes and look forward to enjoying them for a long time.

Love the shoes , but they sent me 2 right shoes and no left. When I emailed to the and let them know they wanted pics , etc. Just sell me 2 left shoes so I can start wearing a pair. Great work shoes

The style or leather material of this shoe has changed regarding the upper and the stitching around the sole has also changed. It now looks more like a "industrial" shoe. The previous model could pass as a "dress" shoe. However it is seems well made and should wear well.

Shoes are comfortable and wear well. Towards the end of life the tread starts to separate from shoe.

They were the most comfortable pair of shoes out of the box. My biggest concern is that the sole separated after 4 months or so and after 5 months their was no tread left.

I continue to buy these shoes for the last 2 decades as they are almost perfect for office/warehouse working environment. I notice a few changes throughout the years, but they are comfortable and can be dress or casual.

I am a woman who likes these shoes and keeps buying a new pair every 2-3 years. I keep 2-3 old pairs on hand for various levels of rough use so the newest pair stays nice. I know this is unusual for a woman, but the shoes are comfortable with soft insoles and reasonably durable leather. I only oil or polish the nice pair a couple times per year. The first place they fail after 4-6 years of use is the sole comes unattached under the toe. Sometimes I glue it back but by then it's really time to get a new pair. The toe stays round and presentable for at least four years.

Great shoes except they the souls wear out to quickly They only last about 6 to 8 months

Very comfortable, great non slip work shoes. Would definitely recommend.

Sides open up and water come in after 6 month and about the time the laces fall apart

This is my second pair. I have a narrow, high arch and this is the most comfortable shoe I have owned in the last 40 years. I do feel however that the bonding glue does break down too early. These shoes were never worn much but over a 5 year period they came dis-bonded. Always stored in the air conditioning. Nothing wrong with the old ones so I'll get them repaired and have 2 pair. Thank you Dr. Scholl's

purchased these about to months ago, use them around the house and at work, great shoe but to many nooks and crannies in the soles, they love doggy do and other types of debris impossible to clean, can't wear them in the house thats why I won't be buying them again.

I was skeptical of buying shoes online, I've been screwed before. These were a perfect fit and feel very comfortable.

The shoe feels good and is comfortable, however the leather exterior needs to be smoother so it can be polished for uniform use. Dr Scholl's used to make a version called a Dr Pete which is one that I used for several years as a police officer and it was very comfortable and light and was great for walking and running when necessary.

I have had several of these over the years. I NEED the built in gel. The sole has migrated over the years to this current that picks up every small stone and blade of grass. You cannot work outside with these soles.

I've owned this shoe for awhile. I believe this is my fifth pair. The shoe does look good and provides me good support. They are comfortable and that is important especially when your on your feet a lot for work. My only problem with the shoes are the sole. I need the slip and oil resistant part of the shoe and it does work. The sole unfortunately picks up everything it comes in contact with making it very dirty and hard to clean. Also the material used on the side of the shoe picks up dust and dirt and causes it not to look good. I have continued to support the brand put wish they would go back to the old sole they had before.

I am a 62 year old female with a bit of arthritis trouble with my toe joints. I needed something with a large toe box to 'rest my joints' as the podiatrist said. Hard to find in women's shoes. So I ordered these men's shoes for my very casual indoor/outdoor shoes. (Dog walking?) They work great - but I'm lucky to have feet big enough for the smallest men's size. Dr. Scholl's should have a women's variety of work shoe that is similar!