Cole Haan

Nantucket Penny

Women's

1st time I didn't care for a Cole Haan purchase. Shoe was way too big, I ordered the size as all my other CHs

Bought these shoes in black in 8.5 for a perfect fit. Liked them so much I ordered the same shoes in blue and pink. Both colors are a more firm fabric than the black and were tight. Exchanged the blue and pink for a 9. They fit better.

I've had 3 pairs (red leather, black patent, tan patent) for several years and I've loved them so much. I ordered the black pebbled a few days ago; they arrived today. Perfect fit and same great quality. Today I ordered the remaining color available, the tan pebble, and they should be here in a few days. What I love about them: timeless style, same great fit, solid quality, durability. I have a leather cleaning kit with a soft brush and saddle soap which keeps my past pairs of shoes looking fabulous. They are my go-to slip ons, very versatile.

Perfect fit my most comfortable and durable loafer. My second pair. I bought pink Nantuckets about four years ago. I wear them a lot in spring and summer and they still look great. I'm so glad I found these I've been wanting this color for a couple years. Thank you Cole Haan

The shoe is definitely true to size. I wouldn't say my foot is narrow but an average width. I purchased the cognac color, the leather is soft and gorgeous. You can wear them for a casual day out or dress them up for work. Also no time needed to break them in, wore them right out of the box. The only thing I am adding is a support for my arch but that's not a big deal.