Vagabond Shoemakers

I have the Livia boot in a 40 and it feels great. The Livia pump is much narrower and uncomfortable. I don't have a wide foot; I'm slim. It's nice looking if you can get it to fit. I'm returning it, unfortunately.

Nice shoe with non-slick sole

The shoe looked two sizes too big but when I tried them on, the foot felt squished and the material would end up wearing out in spots, especially in the toe area as the material is soft. Since I was planning to wear for long hours, I don't think they would be comfortable for multiple hours a day.

The toe bed of the boots was so narrow and flat that it was hard to fit my toes comfortably inside it. Overall the fit was very tight and stiff. Loved the style and color and I'm disappointed the fit was so off. I am usually an 8.5 but sized up. I never have problems with shoes fitting so this is frustrating.

I have difficult feet but I think these boots will be comfortable. They are a good look, can dress up or down.

Boot was too tight across instep and I am fairly flat-footed. Can't imagine anyone with a high instep even being able to put these on. I do not believe the leather would soften enough with wear to make these comfortable.

Very cute. Love these with cropped wide leg pants. Only wore once so far and felt like I was rubbing a blister a little bit so haven't worn them again yet. But Otherwise comfortable. I wear a 9.5 (or 40 in Birkenstocks) and got these in a 10. Feels like a perfect fit, size wise.

Loved the shoe but I am between 7.5 and 8 and this was just too large. Plus it hit a little high on the side under ankle.

Absolutely love these boots! Lots of compliments when I wear these. I found these to be true to size, not necessary to order a size lager. In fact, because of the style, they seemed wider if anything.

Manufacturer discoloration on seam with sole at tip of toe on size 9.

While this boot is grate in style and material it runs a little small I could have used a 1/2 size bigger.

These are beautiful shoes, but were too narrow for me.

Nice square toe box. Paired with arch support inserts for the perfect fit and comfort (I sized up). For my 4’11” frame, I wear with leggings to eliminate chafing from top of boot.

the calf is WAY too wide for us thinner gals

The strap of the Mary Jane was very close to the ankle and wasn't flattering. The fit was just off. I was between two sizes. Had to return these. Nice quality leather. well made.

Took a second to figure out the best method for getting my feet in (I have narrow feet with very high arches). But once you get 'em on, they're AWESOME. They look fantastic - edgy but not too goth, and they're ridiculously comfortable. Fits true to size. Worth every penny.

Sizes run very small, but excellent style and color so I ordered in a larger size.

These are great shoes! Love the look and the color. I usually wear an American size 8.5; the size 8 was a perfect length. They are not tight but they are very close-fitting and one must wear a thin sock, rather than anything heavier or padded such as I wear for long walks. Also they need a little wearing in. No arch support; i added my own inserts.

I love these boots. Sadly I need to use my orthotic insert and it doesn't fit. I will have to return.

Gorgeous color and comfortable. Definitely a keeper. However, size up . They run small.

Was so close to loving these! The toe box was roomy and I actually loved the narrow ankle but I found the vamp--the wart over the top of my foot over the arch was squashed way down. Would probably stretch given the material but I opted for a different style I had ordered

Boot is fabulous, but much more narrow than expected. I need a 1/2 size larger

I ordered a size 7 (37) and you sent me a size 39. Way too big!

Absolutely loved this boot. Perfect heel height, comfortable, walkable. The only issue is the toe, which is beautiful, but makes your foot look sooo long. Probably almost 2 inch space in that beautiful pointy square toe. Sigh....

Maybe because they run a little small, the thong cuts into your foot between your toes. I really wanted to love them because they’re very pretty.