
Franco Sarto
Tinsley Mary Jane Flats
$93.98MSRP: $135.00
5Rated 5 stars out of 5

Great looking shoe, but the materials on the wedge heel looked like stickers. They were bubbly and bumpy look like they were taken off and on a couple times. The shoe is very stiff and very clunky when you walk. But the look of the shoe was great.
Zappos Reviewer on April 04, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Beautiful shoe but HUGE!! I've now returned two pairs and just ordered a third in an attempt to see if it fits. I guess I like the shoe that much to make it worth this hassle. Two times I couldn't wear the shoe when I wanted, two trips to the UPS store to return it. Three times to make sure I was home so the porch pirates wouldn't take my delivery. Holy moley I never had such an issue. Appears by reviews that others had the same sizing. I normally wear a 9.5. I am now whittling down to an 8.5.
Zappos Reviewer from Chicago on April 03, 2026
These are elegant shoes, but they do not fit my feet. They felt both too long and too wide, so my heels slid around and and lifted with each step. Alas, they're going back.
Sharon from Watertown on April 02, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)So pleased with this sandal. The quality of the leather and overall design and construction. Very comfortable too. Great purchase!!!
Mic from Knoxville TN on April 02, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)This is advertised as a leather shoe in the product description. The label on the shoe says all man made material— PU. Very disappointed.
Zappos Reviewer on April 01, 2026
Love this bootie. The construction is excellent as well as the suede. Love the kitten heel! I wear size 7 n Steve Madden and this bootie n size 7 is a perfect fit
Zappos Reviewer on April 01, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Bought these for an outdoor formal event that I needed a dressy flat under my long gown. They were perfect! Wore them all night and they were very comfortable. The closed toe was a perfect polished look while still being comfortable. Sometimes I have trouble with closed toes being tight or pressing against the top of my toes, but these were perfect.
Zappos Reviewer on March 31, 2026
I am really a size 11.5 and these size 11 just needed a hair more room across the toe to fit. Super cute. Wish they made 11.5 or 12.
Zappos Reviewer on March 30, 2026
I really wanted to love these shoes. Unfortunately the ankle straps were to big.
Zappos Reviewer on March 30, 2026
The size turned out to be incorrect—they were too big!The size turned out to be incorrect—they were too big!
Liubov from Brooklyn NY on March 30, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Soft leather, slight cushion, very elegant
Lauren on March 27, 2026
Great beautiful comfortable boots, very stylish - with dress or jeans. Thank you
Elena from Ridgefield Park, NJ on March 27, 2026
I am so happy i bought these in Gold - comfy like sleepers, but look like a million dollars. The first time i wore them - danced the whole night at the wedding - my feet didn’t hurt even a little bit. Definitely recommend. Franco Sarto never fails. Thank you
Elena from Ridgefield Park, NJ on March 27, 2026
Cute shoe, but a little too long for my normally size 7.5 foot.
Zappos Reviewer on March 27, 2026
Lovely shoes, really, but I decided the suede is too impractical for me.
Zappos Reviewer on March 27, 2026
These shoes are true to size, I’m typically a 7 1/2 and purchased the same size and they are super cute flats!
VillageGirl on March 26, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)This is a gorgeous pump--stylish, flattering. Sadly, I cannot wear it as it feels larger than my usual Size 5, both length and width. I feel it would fit a Size 5.5 perfectly.
Geri from Boise on March 26, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)I like these shoes and they look cool. They are comfortable if you’re ok walking with minimal arch support and thin soles. They also run narrow but as someone with narrow feet, that’s perfect for me. I sometimes get 7.5 and sometimes 8 and I got 8 for these to give my toes some space and in case of thick socks.
Zappos Reviewer on March 24, 2026
Simple boots. Comfortable. A bit expensive for being simple.
Zappos Reviewer on March 24, 2026
Way too big around the ankle and constant rubbing on my calf felt painful
Zappos Reviewer on March 23, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Super cute! Very comfortable right out of box. I was worried the inside lining might be rough, but not so.
Kimberly from savannah, ga on March 22, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Love those shoes! I like wearing wedge shoes because they are more comfortable, and can be worn with casual jeans or elegant dress. The pointed toe makes them more feminine. I thought that the pattern on the black shoes would be scratchy on my feet, but it isn't. It has a subtle sheer liner that is soft and not scratchy at all. I also like that it has an adjustable strap in case the leather stretches with time. The shoes have soft padding to make them even more comfortable for longer wear. Perfect shoes for the summer! I only wish they came in other colors like red, or blue.
Anna from Sacramento, CA on March 21, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Had a problem getting the shoes on
Roxanne from Baltimore on March 20, 2026
love them
Zappos Reviewer on March 19, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)This shoe is of very poor quality. The leather is so cheap it feels fake. There's zero arch support. Overall, it's just an ugly shoe.
Zappos Reviewer on March 18, 2026
Review for Zappos Rewards Points
(What's this?)Never miss out on latest drops & sales—plus, new subscribers get 10% off.*
*One code per email address.