Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey 2 Plain Toe

Great fit, great construction, solid quality and details. I bought three similar shoes and chose these because they offered the most support in a light soft soul which is unusual. I only hesitation is that I’m not sure whether the tread will last but we will see. They looked and felt noticeably better than the others.

Very comfortable soft leather. Looks great. Went 1/2" size smaller than I normally wear. Felt tight the first 1-hour of wearing. Then softened up and are very comfortable now. Great shoe.

Comfortable and versatile.

Husband loved:)

Good fit and feel. Casual with no socks and shorts. Fine with pants for a little dressier look. Very versatile. Comfortable.

This shoe is comfortable to wear and was well made. The shoe is longer than I typically have experienced and I could feel the extra length when walking, during the pushing off with your toes action of walking.

Nice contemporary style. A little tighter all around than expected. Not much arch support but relatively comfortable.

Sole of shoe cracked completely across the shoe after wearing only a few times. Because of this, if these are worn outside and it’s raining, feet are soaked. Spent a lot of money on these shoes and cannot wear them. Zappos won’t refund because they’re not in new condition. Out almost $150.