Customer Reviews COACH Natalie Loafer

Love these loafers! Can wear with a sock or without. Very versatile- I will wear with skirts, slack and jeans. I’m a 8.5 or 9 and went with 8.5. Plenty of room.

I returned the first pair due to a deep dent in the top of the shoe. It's patent leather so there was no pushing the dent out, and it was too uncomfortable to wear. As other reviewers noted, my heels slipped out of them as well. But they're cute so I decided to try a different pair. They had a dent in the side of one shoe and came up too high on the ankles. The shoes are of course stiff, so pushing up under the ankles was not was painful. And yes, my heels slipped out of them as well. Just not a good shoe, especially for the price.

I found these to fit true to size. I am usually a 6.5, sometimes 7. I ordered the 6.5 & they fit perfectly.

These shoes look very smart and stylish. I am normally a solid size 9, but will have to return them and order an 8.5. Even with thick socks they were still a half a size to large.

I had to return these, while I think they are absolutely beautiful, they did not fit me at all. I don't have a particularly wide foot or high instep, but I found these really felt snug. I have other pairs of Coach loafers in a 9 and they fit great. If you need any extra room on the top of your foot, or a little forgiving width, these will probably be uncomfortable, or maybe size up. I didn't feel a sizing up would help, so I just returned. But, they are really a beautiful shoe, just did not work for my foot.

The shoes look great, but do not flex while walking. It felt like walking with stones on my feet for eight hours. I am a size 9, but had to order a size 8.5 to fit properly. Also, the heel counter does not have enough curve to hold in my foot heel properly, even adding heel pads did not help, despite the shoe fitting properly. Sadly, I am disappointed these shoes are not comfortable -- at all :(

Im returning these shoes. They are SO stiff, scraped my foot just to get them on. The most uncomfortable pair of shoes I’ve ever bought.