Customer Reviews Trotters Liz

I love this shoe BUT Trotters has a serious quality control issue in sizing. I own and wear a very comfortable 9.5WW Brown. I reordered same as I wore the other out from daily wear. Same size was now a 1/2 inch too long AND too wide. Sent back. Ordered 9.5 W in black and in brown. Black fit like a glove and brown was too narrow and a smidge too short. So now will send back brown and keep black. None in middle of 9.5 W and 9.5 WW so I'm out of luck on brown until.... next month? Reorder same and hope they send me different brown shoe and not the one I just ordered. I do love this shoe over all others so will have to persevere!

Use to wear this shoe some years ago and then the leather came in very tough. This is back to the original softer leather. One has to wear this shoe for awhile for it to conform to the foot. It is a nice shoe

These are so dark navy, they look black. I put them next to my black shoes and even in sunlight, you can't tell the difference in color.

I have always worn a 10 but due to an injury most 10s are short for my right foot. When I move up to 10.5 the width seems to be a problem - too wide. Finally found these Trotters that fit perfectly in a 10.5. Going back for other colors.

I love these shoes. Very comfortable! Only complaint is that the woven part of the shoe makes little squeaky noises when it bends, but that doesn't stop me from loving them!

I have owned 5 pairs of these over the past 4 years - they are an economic alternative to Cole-Haan flats. There is some variability to the fit when the size is 11N (the ecru flats are simply too narrow), but overall they are good for professional wear.

Lovely shoe, soft weave. Ordered wide but found shoe to be very narrow (as narrow as my usual size 11B). This shoe would probably break in very well for most feet. I am going to try the extra wide, then decide. Fairly cushy sole for this type of shoe. Very little arch support.

The width is accurate but the heel is large and does not hug the foot well-otherwise the shoe is good looking and comfortable.

We gals with wide feet should love this shoe. Nice quality and classic style. It was a half size too large though.

I just ordered the wrong size, having searched for my former brands that were all leather uppers and sole with steel shanks. When I found this and read the reviews I had to try them. The selection I ordered is too short; hence, maybe too narrow, but glory it felt like a dream on my feet. Remembering what a foot specialist once told me, I'm trying to find a larger size, but the selection is limited here; I've put in for an alert if they come in. I'll buy many pair of this shoe. It's attractive, leather (which means it will take good shining), comfortable, and classic. If they only made a sling-back patent, I'd be in hog-heaven. My grading was only due to having the wrong size; hoping I can re-order something fast.

Nice shoe, comfortable right from the start and well made. I liked the look over just a plain leather shoe.

These shoes are comfortable if you know how to walk in them correctly. At first I put too much weight on the balls of my feet, which got me corn. Now I put weight pretty evenly all throughout my feet and they work just fine. I think the problem was that the soles are somewhat thin and hard, even though the insoles are soft. Overall these are good shoes for my business casual work environment. I would probably buy them again at a lower price.

These shoes are comfortable and a bit stylish. They work well with pants for work.

Comfortable and stylish; these are great to have shoes. They run a little large, but I am very happy to have these shoes. They are practical and good looking shoes for the office or jeans. They appear to be wearing very well. I am happy with this purchase.

I love these shoes! But after I had worn them only twice, the soles separated from the uppers at both toes. I would normally have sent them back at this point but instead, I decided to glue them myself with an adhesive specifically designed for the purpose. They are fine once again. I would still recommend this shoe.

Loved this shoe but it ran a little tighter than other narrows. Heel was perfect but my toes felt very cramped. So nice to actually have a shoe that fit in the heel w/o slipping. I need to try it in a 1/2 size larger but unfortunately, they are out of that size and color.

Strange...I have these shoes in Navy and love them. Ordered the same size in Black and they are too tight. Maybe I need a wider pair.

I put these shoes on and wore them immediately. A little tight in the toe area. Otherwise a nice fit.

These are very comfortable shoes... nice enough to wear to work, even when I end up walking around all day. However, note that the bottom is started to get extremely scuffed already. It's not compromising the shoe yet, but I will keep an eye on it.