Customer Reviews Circus NY by Sam Edelman Yulia

Beautiful boot....wish I could keep them. The description stated an 11.5 inch shaft, I have a slimmer leg and thought these would be perfect. The shaft is absolutely huge!! Well beyond even a standard, though a "wide calf" is not part of the description. So disappointed. Is anything made for slim people anymore, or have all companies gone woke and only cater to the oversized?

They are gorgeous but sadly the wide calf wasn’t wide enough. Broke my heart to not be able to zip these beauty’s up. Check the calf circumstance as didn’t fit 16 inches. But there beautiful.

I have med to wide feet and a bunion. The medium width was perfect. I have athletic calves 15.6 . The reg calf was perfect. I first tried the wide calf because it stated the reg calf was 14.1 Way too loose. The thing to remember is that for most boots, the calf widths are usually based on size 6 and they go up in small increments with each half size up. If I had understood that from the get go, it wouldn't have taken me so long to find new boots!

I tried to order the chocolate brown boot, but received the black boot instead. Loved it, but I don't need a pair of black boots, so exchanged it for the chocolate brown. Love the style and comfort, but the color had a purplish tinge that I don't like, and also don't love the gold label on the back, so am going to return it

These boots aren’t as pictured. They are really wide in the calf and the foot. The leather doesn’t feel like quality leather.

These are gorgeous boots but they had just a little too much of a yellow tone to go with my wardrobe often enough to keep. Beautifully made, roomy in the calf, I wish I could’ve made them work but that color just wasn’t doing it for my color palette. If you’re a blonde maybe they’ll work better for you?

I didn't expect to like these boots as much as I do! They super comfortable are my usual size in Sam Edelman boots. The full zip makes them much easier to get on and off and the kitten heel is just tall enough to elongate your legs but short enough to be practical to walk in. The brown suede is also a true chocolate/espresso brown - it is not lighter in person. I personally love the pointed toe because it makes the boot look more sophisticated, but it does mean there's an extra 1/2-1" in the toe box so if you have big feet you may not like that. I have small feet and these definitely made my feet look bigger but I don't mind it.

I have a medium widish foot. The boot fit well in the toe area, not squished up in spite of the pointy toe. I ordered my normal size 6. Very cute boot. I would have kept it but the calf area was too narrow. If you have a normal calf size, this would be perfect. I managed to zip it up (barely) but my 14" calves were uncomfortable.

Beautiful boots but not petite girl friendly. I’m 4’11 and when I sat down the boots bent at the back of my knees.

The circumference isn't a regular fit. It's larger than regular fit. The color is beautiful. Sadly I returned them.

wide calf and too big

I love these boots! The foot is true to size. I wish the calf was just a tad bit wider. I will have to stretch the calf area

the front of the shoes is a tight fit, I suggest ordering half a size up

Love the low heels and stylish pointed toe look

These boots are very cute and comfortable.

The color is exactly what I wanted, it's an off white/cream/ecru vs tan. I love the shape of the small heel, something different. I will say the calf area of the boot feels a little bit big to me. I've only worn them once so far, but they actually made my wide leg jeans pucker where the calf of the boot was. Not a deal breaker but something to keep in mind. I have a very normal sized calf and there is lots of room in that area of the boot.

Do not hesitate on these perfect boots! They’re so comfortable & stylish! I danced all night in them! I love them so much. I purchased 4 pairs!

I ordered a size too large. They are beautiful boots, but I have to return them.

I measured the inside of the top of this boot.: 15.25 inches, NOT 12 inches. Does anyone make boots for small to average-sized calves?

Seemed very narrow to me, I do have bunions however. Didn’t feel comfortable enough overall to keep but style and color was great.

Dark chocolate suede is purple!

The circumference of the boot calf was too wide. It states that it is a narrow calf and it was not very narrow. I needed to return them.

The fit was great but the quality of the suede was low.

fit good quality not good.