Customer Reviews Eastland 1955 Edition Classic II

These loafers in a wide width are only wide in the heel. The front of the shoe is still rather narrow. The heel is so big they fall off my feet in the back with every step I take. I tried going down a half size, but those were too short in the toe area and still loose in the heel. They are great-looking shoes, but sadly I have to return them.

Very long and no support.

When my regular size 8.5M was not available, tried size 8.5W. It was a bit too wide for me but luckily size 8.5M came available, so I ordered that. Sadly, this size was too narrow and hurting my left foot. Also, I've become actually stupefied by the fact that these shoes are claimed to be all leather - inside and out. I cannot believe they're not vegan leather, at best. Returned.

Far too narrow for a medium foot. I thought maybe it had been mislabeled. Returned.

Classic loafer which I love, but too tight across top of the foot and very loose in the heel.

The fit is true to size, but the material looks like cheap plastic. Would not repurchase.

It wasn't the quality I expected. It had an awkward rounded top to the toe which I didn't notice in the display images and one shoe had leather stains.

This shoe is nowhere near as well-made or as attractive as Sebago’s Plaza. As far as sizing is concerned though, I normally wear a 9W and I found this 9W to be a bit sloppy in both length and width. Might have been OK with a sock, but I like the Sebago Plaza so much better that I’m sending these back regardless.

Poor fit, poorly made, weird feel to leather Definitely not how I remember Eastland

The top, where the toes live, is so hard and painful. I couldn't even wear them all day!

This shoe was so small I couldn’t get my foot in it! Returning.

The fit and size were fine, however the leather was very stiff and they looked very cheap.

The shoe ran very small.

These were almost comical. They were tiny, tiny, tiny. I always wear a 7 or 7 1/2, I went with a 7 1/2 and decided to get a wide width as the last pair of Eastlands I've had were a bit narrow. I couldn't even come close to getting my feet into these shoes. They are at least two sizes too small, maybe 3 sizes too small. Zappos stellar shipping, returns and customer service makes this an easy return.

they were way to big and I returned them.

The leather and workmanship of these shoes is amazing. Their sizing is absolutely ridiculous. I ordered an 8W - which is my normal size. I could not even fit my foot into the shoe. It was more like a 7 narrow.

My shoe size was too small even tho I wear size 10 these shoes were too small, I need to return them and I don’t know how to do it

They were quite narrow when marked as a wide width

The seam along the toe looked cheap and like it might start to show wear quicker than I want. I went with the sam edelman loraine loafer which has a much nicer seam along the toes.

I ordered a 7 1/2 W. The shoe was at least once inch longer than my foot and so tight I couldn't even get it on. I had to recheck the shoe to make sure the wrong size wasn't sent. It wasn't. Looked more like a 9 narrow.

I made a big mistake buying these shoes. There is a reason why they are so cheap. I have had to buy inserts as there is literally nothing between my foot and the sole of the shoe. They are not at all comfortable if you have to do any walking or standing.

Nice style, but BAD shoe. The leather is too stiff, the toebox is too narrow, the heel & the rest of the show is wider than other "medium" widths. There is NO arch support & the lining only goes up to the ball of the foot & then NOTHING. There is a seam right under the ball of the foot that is quite uncomfortable. I suppose if you wear thicker socks you won’t notice this. Also, it does run about 1/2 size larger than marked so size down 1/2 size on this one. Also, the leather is not of the best quality & I don’t think it would "break-in" like the older leather that was used on these shoes way back when.