Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Collection Dudley Plane Toe

I LOVE these shoes. I have been a J&M fan for a long time. I have a several pairs of (nicer) shoes, and I am rather picky about my shoes. The leather quality is wonderful. I absolutely love the soles. It's difficult to find anything but rubber soles anymore. Thank you J&M for creating an affordable, high quality, stylish shoe! I wore these last Sat. night, and, I received several compliments from a variety of people. I wear a lot of nice shoes, but have never had the compliments I've had with these. BTW -- I loved the first pair of these I purchased (olive) so I ordered a second pair (dark gray) today. Highly recommended!

Love these shoes! The olive color is unique and stands out. Wish you had a belt to match, but I found one online. I have always had great luck with J&M. Been wearing a couple of my pairs for 25 years. Durable and great quality! Thanks

These shoes go well with Jeans, Chinos, Slacks. Pairs well with a button down shirt tucked or untucked. The gray with brown stitching on the shoe gives plenty of versatility to wear different color schemes. These shoes seem to be breaking in nicely and I look forward to continued comfort. If you're looking for a classy, but stylish shoe that can be worn with different outfits then this is the shoe for you.

After a two day break in period. These have become my most comfortable shoes. The look with dark jeans is fitting enough for a dressy casual look. Definitely not a common pair of shoes.

Great looks comfortable however for those of us with wide feet it could be a slight challenge. I love this shoe I'll use a shoe horn to stretch the width.

The fit great and got many compliments recently when worn at a formal wedding!

I love the quality of the shoe, from the leather to the sole. Almost like a work of art.

An exquisite pair of dress shoes for any Occassion. Superb craftsmanship and style.

Love the shoes. The laces seem to short for the shoes. I was surprised Johnston & Murphy did not carry the shoe polish (olive) for these shoes. I would have purchased some

Love these

Like so many of J&M's calfskin beauties this shoe is a delight. Comfortable, elegant, and highly shined they pair marvelously with jeans, khakis, or a blue or tan suit. I'm so glad to have them in my closet.

Good quality, good fit, a little hard to break it.

These shoes look great. But not comfortable I wear them for 2-3 hours. My experience is after all subjective. Improved comfort would make these shoes perfect.

Beautiful color and grain. The olive color is sharp. They are true to size for me. I was hoping they were as soft as the Dudley Lug boot but not even close. They'll require some break in but i think they're going to be great once they soften up.

The shoes look great. But they were to tight, I need them to be a little bit wider.

I am very pleased with the Johnston & Murphy Dudley Plain Toe in Olive Green. These shoes are like a work of art, beautifully crafted and extremely comfortable. The unique olive green color is stunning and even darker than it appears in the photos, which I find makes them even more versatile. I also appreciate the elegant wood grain detail on the sides, which adds a touch of sophistication. Comfort-wise they excel with noticeable cushioning at the ball of the foot, making them a pleasure to wear all day. The sizing was in line with my other Johnston & Murphy shoes, which made selecting the right fit easy. Overall, these shoes are an excellent blend of style, comfort, and quality. Highly recommended!

The color caught my eye so i ordered them. The calf skin is soft and supple and the texture is amazing. I love to see the grain and the way the dye and polish make it unique.

Too shiny. Doesn't match the sole.

I love the look and style of this shoe. Its an eye catcher. However, the shoes size runs small. I was very disappointed that I had to return the shoes because I could not get my foot inside of them. If your feet can fit in them go and get them. I gave two stars because J&M continue to make beautiful shoes but undersized shoes.

These are utilitarian in form, and strikingly beautiful in their simplicity. Quality and craftsmanship are unimpeachable. Dapper, meets Bauhaus.

Last color to go on sale due to demand. Glad I waited and worth waiting for.

I love the shoes' quality, they look very nice

Love the color and quality of these shoes. Fit is spot on.

The shoes are eye catching and a statement of quality. Comfortable and elegant!