Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden II

I typically wear a size 7. Sometimes I am a 6 1/2. I bought a size, and they are just a tiny bit too big. It turns out this is a good thing though. The soles are hard and have no support. The extra space gave me room to add my own cushioning/support. Once I added the cushioning, they became comfortable enough. I am going to keep them. Personally, I think I paid too much for a pair of boots whose soles felt like standing on bricks.

These look cute and are comfortable, but they are not warm. I wore them for a walk in 20-degree, weather and my feet were freezing.

I normally wear an 8 but these were an 8 wide. They have no cushioning whatsoever and immediately hurt my feet. They're going back

I was barely able to get it on with no socks and I ordered a half size larger so I could wear heavier socks. Very sad! I needed new boots.

sizing was fine I have had 2 pair of these my others are very comfortable these are not they are hard inside not soft and comfy

I wrote a review on these when I had worn them only twice. I said that they were not comfortable, but with Dr. Scholl's they became comfortable and just needed to break in. I wore them a few more times and I am now returning them. They will not break in and stop giving me blisters on my heels.

Cute boot and I needed this color. But it was quite short and narrow. I even sized up 1/2 a notch. If remotely comfortable I would have kept them. But this was a no go for me. They seem to be cutting shoes/boots smaller and narrower these days.

The boot was not flexible.

Felt very cheap and not comfortable at all .

Very flimsy material with NO INSULATION or cushioning. Returned. Columbia has become a trash brand. Zappos should vet theses companies.

The tongue of the boot is stiff and will not lay flat. This makes them very uncomfortable

Ordered as a gift. Was too loose on foot. Must return