Customer Reviews Naturalizer Shay

The fit was true to size. I bought 8W because that what I buy in Brooks Glycerin shoes. Overall a decent fit, heel was a bit wide still looking for socks that are thick enough to take up slack. They look great, the metallic finish was a nice touch I finally had snazzy shoes that were comfortable to walk a few blocks in NYC!

Nice fashion sneaker. Not for fitness. Has a high toe box, but too narrow at the toe for a wide size foot. Stiff sole.

I kept these and they are comfortable enough, although I'd like more room in the toe box. I wear a wide and these just barely fit better than medium width. No arch support to speak of. I like the them but they do make my feel look really long.

Color not as in the photo... I returned these

High comfort

TOO BIG

Cute just too big

I really liked the metallic finish and the color on this sneaker. But I thought the sneaker was too klunky looking. Returning them.

The shoes were narrow then most others I have tried on. Tried 1/2 size up and still narrow to my feet.

These were comfortable. The color wasn't right for me.

Pretty shoe. Unfortunately, they are too wide for me. I hate returning them

Loved these shoes in pewter; however, fit was uncomfortably tight in both length and width. I ordered 6.5 M, and I’ve never worn anything other than 6 or 6.5.

Looks pretty but no support.

It fit well

These were so cute! But they are very heavy like a wearing a chunk of rubber, and almost no arch support. So they are going back.

The orange is NOT bright orange, more of a subtle burnt orange which was disappointing. Definitely a finalist for comfy all-day travel shoes but the look was not bright and fun, more "sensible and mature".

They didn’t look good on my feet. Thought they were cute, just not for me

Shoe did not feel too big actually. It slipped at the heel more than it should. I do have a narrow heel. Otherwise, it is a really nice attractive shoe.

I wear a 9W shoe and this she rubbed on the side of my big toe where there’s a seam where the white & black leather meet, causing it to rub. Returned shoe because I didn’t want a blister. Guess I have to stick with Brooks, but the pretty colors don’t come in wide widths!

The front part of the shoe felt like like a big pot hole. Could not believe they weren't more comfortable for tennis shoes. Returned.