Customer Reviews Naturalizer Astrid

In my 50s and comfort comes over style these days….this shoe satisfies both categories!

They seemed cute but even after selecting the "wide" option they were still too narrow for my foot. The Naturalizer 27 Edit Abilyn Black Leather shoe was a much better fit for a wide foot with a similar style.

Fantastic good looking comfortable shoes I love them

I got a half size shorter than I normally do but they fit perfectly. I wore these for a full workday and didn't have any discomfort, and the arch support was great. I also received many compliments on how beautiful they were.

Beautiful shoe but too narrow in the wide size. I ordered several styles in 8W from Naturalizer and this one was significantly more narrow in the ball of foot + toe area than all the other shoes. I liked the look of these the best so I tried sizing up to 8.5W but it didn't help - still too narrow in the toes. Very disappointed that I can't keep this shoe, it's beautiful but way too narrow. Not a true W at all. Naturalizer should make the same style but in the width of the Amber and Abilyn - those two shoes were true to width and very comfortable.

Just too big

These shoes are extremely comfortable, can spend all day in them or be at an entire party in them. These are your everyday heels!

Great heels

It looked great and felt great, but on a personal level the heel was just too high for me. If I could do the heel height, I would have definitely kept it!

I struggle with finding shoes that are comfortable yet stylish and these shoes hit every mark. Will definitely purchase another pair in a different color!

really gorgeous shoe. although the straps were floppy on me. they should be made narrower as they looked a bit messy. otherwise its a gorgeous shoe and pretty comfortable when i first tried it.

I’ve never worn such a comfortable pair of heels!!!! I got these in rose gold for a wedding and they were easy to wear all night. I have wide feet and short toes and a wide toe box and somehow this just made everything work. I want it in multiple colors now

Easy to wear. Vintage vibe. Comfortable for a pointy toe

I needed to order this in a wide due to the shape of my foot but these are gorgeous, flattering and elegant shows. They will elevate any outfit

Beautiful, quality shoe. Lots of compliments at the wedding I wore them to. I don't wear heels ever these days, and was able to wear these for a few hours before my feet started to hurt, so I felt like that was pretty good. Would recommend.

I love this shoes. Very nice and comfort

I love this shoes. So comfort

Perfect fit and size. Sooo comfortable and looks great.

What a cute shoe. What a great color! Not a classic red, not orange, not pink - but it seems to blend with all of these. I know that seems impossible! I bought it to wear to a wedding this month and found three more things in my closet they would go with, right away! Yay! They are comfortable for a pointy toed shoe.

Good quality