Customer Reviews Cole Haan Paxton Maryjane Pump

I've been eyeing these shoes for a month or so and finally decided to get them. I love the color and vibe idea, however they are an awkward fit. There is some serious toe cleavage - all the way to the top knuckle, which I don't like the look of. wish they had a model in the images so you could see before you buy. Also, the fit was off for me. For reference, I have a wide toe area, high arches, and narrow heels. The toe box was very tight and I was slipping out of the heel at the same time.

These are soooo cute. But like all Cole Han shoes, they run very narrow. I wish they came in wide widths, sadly will have to return.

It is a very lovely shoe but my feet may not be right for them. My feet are an M width but on the high side of that. I am personally not a fan of “toe cleavage” so these will require some opaque hose if I keep them. For those of you with dainty feet and slim toes, definitely give them a try!

Bought the burgundy color. So, so pretty. The velveteen bumps it up so much. But, that doesn't matter if it doesn't fit or is uncomfortable. Was so happy to find out that they are comfortable and there is some arch support. Can wear them for so many occasions. Will probably buy the black pair now since these are comfortable. Otherwise I will regret it.

These look great on. Very stylish and comfortable. There is plenty of room in the toe box plus a comfy footbed. Love them.

Super adorable, super comfortable! True to size.

Loved them out of the box. Stylish and comfortable. Sturdy heel good enough to wear when commuting. Very comfortable for all day wear. I wore them sightseeing around Belgium - very comfortable, even on cobblestone streets.

Pretty for work and overall comfortable

This is the most comfortable Maryjane! It isn't too tight in the toe box and the heel height is comfy for walking and standing for long periods of time. I plan to purchase in all colors & hope for more!

Sized up a half size as I ordered the Patent Leather shoe. Extremely happy with these shoes. Very versatile. They will get a lot of use.

Holy toe cleavage. Unfortunately this didn't work for me. It also fit a little snug. So cute otherwise! The heel height was perfect.

These shoes are adorable, unfortunately the fit on these is super weird. My foot is slightly wide, and these shoes ended up being waaaaay too narrow. Even if I sized up, the shoe wouldn’t fit correctly. They do that thing where you can see the bottom half of my toes, which is not the look I’m going for lol. It’s really unfortunate because they are so cute. Waited too long to return them, so now they just sit pretty on my shoe rack. Don’t buy these if you’re looking for comfort!

The silver was scraped off right out of the box. Doesn’t bode well for wearing them. Returned. But they were cute.