Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Vicki Pump

These were slightly too long which made walking in them difficult and painful. I unfortunately chose to wear them to an event, untested - shame on me for not doing a proper try on with these before leaving the house in them. They are beautifully made, and look great- I am sad I have to donate them because I can’t wear them again. I may try to re order them in a smaller size; will update this review if I do!

These are a lovely, well-made basic black pump. I wear a 9.5-10 and the 9.5 in these fit great. Very soft inside and the block heel is very comfortable to wear for long periods of time. I prefer a more pointed toe, but I can live with this more rounded one.

These shoes run large. I would say size down a full or half size. They are very cute, and look well made. Unfortunately I did not see any sizes below 6. I usually wear a 6 or 6.5 and found the 6 to be far too big.

Shoe size ordered too large

Too grumpy for me.

This was a lovely shoe, but it had clearly been worn and returned - scuffs on the bottom and visible creases in the leather. If not for this -- I would have kept the shoe.

I’m a true 6 1/2. I heeded the reviews and sized down to a 6, the smallest size available. These shoes were falling off my feet. Not even close to a 6, they fit more like a 7. It’s a pity because they are well made, the interiors are soft and heel height is perfect for work. Back they went.

Much larger than 7.5 should fit. Toe very pointy