Customer Reviews Propet Yara Mary Jane

I have very difficult feet to fit well. These seem to be just right. Since I have flat feet, however, I had to add additional arch support, but this is not the fault of the shoe. The adjustable strap made it easy to add arches. Love the shoes and wish there were more colors.

Too small and inner sole too hard for my feet.

Looks great. Feels comfortable, not heavy as some flats do. 1 inch heel is perfect.

Cute. Leather looked good. Just a little too wide in the heel for Mom. (Bought in 6 wide).

This shoe is beautiful, but ran narrow for me. I returned it for a wider fitting shoe.

My search for a mary jane shoe is over many shoes later! My hard to fit feet (10.5 ww) are finally happy! The only thing I would change is to do away with the hook and loop closure, at least ones didn't bother to fake the buckle look, but I'd rather have the real deal and feel more secure in them. All in all, I am thrilled to finally have a sensible dressy shoe to wear and appreciate the ability to return and even exchange shoes. Lastly, buyer beware that these shoes run a full size large, so down size for sure.

These are good shoes. I have good luck with the fit from Prophet, and these look just like the photos. I'm happy-- and if Prophet ever decides to start making shoes that are a little more chic, I'll be first in line!

I liked these, but the space for the height of my big toe is too tight.

Just tried on. Under toes no cushion. Slid even though smaller size would be tight. Returning cuz under toes just felt like walking on the sole. Cute so disappointed

Cute, versatile shoe. I had originally ordered my normal size which is 8 WW but the shoe seemed to run long. I just received the 7.5 WW and it is much better. The stylish straps which go across the shoe keeps one from walking out of them and visually slims the foot. I would recommend taking out the insert and putting your own in for a little more comfort. I've been looking for a long time for a black flat that could be worn with black dress pants and after ordering probably eight different styles I'm done looking for something that didn't hurt my feet. I believe I've finally found them, I'll be keeping these!

Very comfortable cute shoe. I have very wide feet which are often hard to fit due to a bunion. I need shoes which have taller toe boxes since the bunion is where shoes often cut across the top of your foot. The nice soft leather on these shoes doesn't bother me. The only thing is they seem to run a half size bigger than my normal size. I'm ordering the next size down to see if they fit better. Overall I would highly recommend.

Perfect right out of the box. I bought the 6WW and they are excellent. Very comfortable with the adjustable (velcro) strap across the top. With my longer jeans these look like ballet flats which is what I was going for. These need thin socks (dress socks) to go with them or no socks I suppose. The back of the shoe did not rub and I wore them around the house for a couple of hours.

The shoes are pretty comfortable right out of the box and it's a neutral shoe which should match everything in my wardrobe.

A very comfortable pair of shoes! They are very well-made. Highly recommended.

These shoes seem well made and more feminine than some of the other MaryJane's for WW feet. Unfortunately, they aren't comfortable for my swollen feet. They were tight across the front. I'm fairly certain this wouldn't be a problem for "unswollen" feet.

The width was fine but the heel was too big. Cute shoe tho

These run large. But they are so so comfy

I got these for my mom, who needed an easy-on pair of shoes. Her shoe size due to corns has increased to extra wide width for comfort. This shoe was wide enough in the toe box to accommodate that (it did not press against her corns), but the heel was unfortunately too big to stay on.

Good shoe, but heel was too wide.

ordering down a size

Fit is good, though the heel is slightly too large. I needed shoes for concert performances and these worked perfectly for me.

The shoe is super cute but I hate the velcro closure. It makes it impossible to just slip on and go, and I know after awhile the velcro will get full of hair and fuzz and no longer latch properly. Plus it's very narrow velcro so you have to be very precise when placing it. I will be returning these.

These fit well and were decently comfortable. The wide was truly wide. Wasn't sold on the style with the slight wedge. Honestly returning because I think my mom has these, and I don't need the same shoes.

The leather upper is very nice and the heel was good. Unfortunately, I find this brand to have different widths than listed. This shoe is not a wide width.