Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari - Nubuck Leather

I love these Birks! The fit is narrower and a bit less boxy than the Milano/Arizona models, which is great for my regular width/slightly narrow foot. They’re comfortable right out of the box, look great, and are definitely one of the cutest and best fitting pairs of sandals I’ve had in a long time. I do wish the buckles were silver, rather than copper colored, but I’m not losing sleep over it.

I am usually a size 7 but I ended up buying the size 5-5.5 equivalent (36) because the 38 I was “supposed” to fit was way too big for my feet and the 37 still left a big gap in the heel. I’ve worn mine on and off for two weeks and they’re pretty much broken in. The straps closest to the ankles rubbed the tops of my feet for awhile but that’s mostly gone away. A useful tip is that the Birkenstock shoebox has a guide in the lid to help find your correct shoe size if yours ends up wrong.

I love these - with all Birks make sure you slowly break them in at first few hours a day - it will be so worth it . I will say I think they are a little big but I’m keeping them - I wear a 7-7.5 I. Shoes and 8 in sneakers and I got a 38 and they are a little big .

I love these! They are so comfortable and I have worn them every day since I got them. I read others’ reviews before purchasing and ordered a size down and they fit perfectly.

I have worn Teva Mush sole shoes for years and was in need of something with more support for my aging flat feet. I opted to try Birks, having heard great testimonies. I love this style! I ordered my suggested size, a 39. I am normally a 7.5 W and these were way too long. I wanted these to work, but had to send them back. I will try the next size down.

I love these shoes! Took about a week to break in but now they’re so comfortable and I wear them all over my college campus!

I absolutely love these shoes! It took about a week to break them in, but the more I wear them the more comfortable they get. The shoes form around your feet so they’re really comfortable once broken in. I also was unsure about the part around the toe because it looked uncomfortable, but it isn’t at all! I wear these shoes all over a college campus walking to and from classes. I will definitely be buying another pair of Birkenstocks soon!

I have very narrow feet, especially heels. These were too wide.

Glad to finally have some more Birkies. Wore them in the 80's. My feet are wide, with a narrow heel, and hard to fit. These are super comfortable, and the only reason I gave 4 stars for comfort is because I have a sore toe from a bunion. I love the toe piece, that sort of aligns your foot correctly. They were perfect from the moment I put them on. I have neuromas, bunions, plantar fasciitis, etc etc and they are truly appreciated.

LOVE these but definitely should've ordered a smaller size. I am a size 6 95% of the time -- sadly I fell into the 5% this time.

Great fit, nice look, very comfortable! My gf loves these.

So comfy and cute! Love these!!

These sandals are so cute and comfy. I normally wear a size 8.5-9 but I ordered a 39 and they work well. I tried narrow but wound up liking the regular fit because my toes are more squared off than angled down like Birks make them. Under the straps is soft so they were comfortable the first time I wore them. Do your feet a favor and purchase these :)

I absolutely love these shoes! This is the third pair that I’ve purchased so I have a color to wear with nearly every outfit. Very comfortable and they look cute with jeans, shorts, or capris.

Love these sandals. They are cute and not clunky at all. If you want to try Birkenstocks but don’t want the Jesus sandals, give these a try! You’ll fall in live with the brand and the comfort.

These are perfect all around sandals. They go with everything! I love them so much, that when I lost them :( I bought another pair as soon as I could!

These are a Mother's Day gift for my Mom because I loved the ones that I bought for myself so much. These sandals are so comfy that I wear them all the time. I'm about to buy a pair in a different color as well.

So cute!

These are my first pair of Birkenstocks and they definitely won’t be my last. Super cute and very comfortable. I wear B width shoes typically and the narrow fit perfectly.

Love, love these sandals. As a person who has only ordered Birkenstock soft bed previously I was pleasantly surprised that these are this comfortable. It could be that the 'softness' is worn down on all my other Birks because they last so long. These are dressier looking than other styles I have, which can now be retired to everyday sandals. I ordered the Birko-flor as opposed to the leather and the finish is very nice. Zappos I don't know how you do the speedy delivery but it is much appreciated as are the free returns!

Excellent sandal for spring! Love that is comes I. A narrow width!

Only thing I would change on the Mayari is adding an option for leather & an option for the soft footbed. Otherwise, I love these!

I have worn Birkenstocks for years and was happy that sizing is so consistent.

A nice change from my usual Arizonas. I was a little concerned about the comfort of the toe strap when I first put them on but was pleasantly surprised at how quickly they became comfy. There is always a "break-in" with Birks but it was pretty short with these. Glad I made the purchase.