Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari - Nubuck Leather

It's not the quality I expected from Birkenstock. These sandals are completely falling apart considering I only use them as house shoes. I'm very disappointed of the quality.

Think I got a fake. Shows showed up in unlabeled box. Really disappointed Zappos…. Immediately returned

Came in an unlabeled box, don't even know if these are fakes. Really disappointed Zappos.

toe strap uncomfortable, can't keep these for the price

DO NOT ORDER BIRKENSTOCKS ON ZAPPOS!! YOU WILL NOT RECEIVE ORIGINAL BOX. WILL ARRIVE iN A PLAIN CARDBOARD BOX.

Bought these sandals a year ago and it is falling apart already. The comfort was good while it last. The sad thing is I never wore them outside only indoors as I have a heel spur and the arch support alleviates pressure on my heel. I purchased a previous pair 6 years ago wash them a few times and it looks and feels better than these. Things are so poorly made theses days. Birkenstock’s quality can’t substantiate the price.

Toe loop pulled out of sole, rendering the sandals worthless after a little over a year of use. Pricey for short lifespan and no warranty.

Not narrow

Poor quality for Birkenstock! Sandal feels like it’s hard plastic, very uncomfortable. Returned them.

These fell apart after two months of regular wear! The toe part completely came out of the footbed. It’s disappointing because these aren’t cheap sandals!

The shoe overall was so stiff and the sole so hard and inflexible that I can hardly make any judgments regarding size. I did not like the shiny faux leather--did not realize it was shiny from the photos of it. The strap between my toes was sharp-edged and uncomfortable.

They were good until the strap came off randomly. Now they are unuseable.

They didn't last 6 months before starting to crack at the sole. I do not wear these daily and only wear when I leave the house. I contacted Birkenstock and they told me I can take it to a repair shop on my expense. My knock off Shopko sandals lasted longer than these! Would not recommend!

the shoe was too hard for my foot.

Hurt feet, no support! Returned as couldn’t stand to wear 2 minutes.

This pair of birkenstocks is exactly the same a pair I purchased 5 years ago. I have worn those every summer for 5 years and finally need to replace them. This pair that I ordered seems CHEAP...like cardboard. Holding the old in one hand and the new in my other, there is really no comparison. I feel like the quality of the new pair is less than adequate, especially for Birkenstocks reputation and the high price of their shoes.

Way too narrow and really uncomfortable. Sadly they had to go back even though they were super cute.

For the first time ever, very disappointed in the condition of shoes received from Zappos. I ordered and was charged for the oiled leather, but feel that the incorrect pair of shoes was sloppily placed in the box. Sadly they will be returned as the fit is perfect. Thank you Zappos for always making ordering and returning so easy.

Not good for people with thinner toes and smaller feet. The 4.5 fit more like a 5 to 5.5. The strap fit too loose in the toe.

I wear almost exclusively Birkenstocks, I think my body has actually molded around the Birko floor and something was off about these. They didn’t come in the Birkenstock box, which is just a side note - more importantly they hurt my feet, and they didn’t feel symmetrical. I’ve worn this style with the black oiled leather, and have a brown pair with the ankle straps so this seemed like a pretty easy purchase - but sadly will have to return these. It’s possible I just received a bad pair.

The sandal itself is comfortable and stylish. I wore them periodically over the summer months in 2021. After three months averaging 2 - 3 times a week, the foot bed adjacent to the leather strap started cracking. I asked if I could return them yet was told no because I wore them outside over a few months. I’m disappointed that the quality did not match the price point. I’m 5’7” and 140lbs. I wear a size 9 narrow. I expected the sandal to last behind one season. I will purchase again yet though Nordstroms in case of defect to protect my investment.

There’s a defect in the toe area. The loop that you got your toe in is too big. It’s a manufacturer error. I have another pair of these shoes and they’re fine.

Right shoe not made right big gap under bottom strap near right ankle. Appears the buckle itself was not center and not aligned. I bought these for a beach wedding on Sunday 2/20/22. I did contact CS when received. I was offered a new pair by Sunday Eve. I needed them for afternoon and couldn’t risk not having them for wedding in afternoon. I was given a $20 credit. I’m still not happy. They don’t support my right ankle line it should. Just wanted to share this with your team. Thanks

The sandals were slippery. On tile floors too much slipping and slipping… sent back

Would have kept these sandals if tread were not so slippery. My tile floors….. slipping and sliding… sent back