Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Collection Jenson Plain Toe

I bought these to have a dressier, but still-comfortable shoe to wear to work. One of my employers complimented me on them the first day I wore them. I'll be eager to see if they hold up over time. I usually wear a size 13 at J&M, but these are more snug when I put in my arch-support insole. I have relatively narrow feet so I was a little surprised at the snug forefoot fit.

This will be second pair of the same shoe. I have never ordered a second pair of the same shoes in my life, and I'm 54. I wear these nearly every work day and have them very comfortable and have received many compliments on them. The only real wear has been a smoothening of the sole over time.

My favorite pair of JM's

All the comfort of calf-skin and the style that can only be J&M, now with an understated sneaker sole, or should it be soul?

Extremely comfortable shoe. First time I have purchased a pair of Johnston and Murphy shoes. Will not be the last.

Received many compliments each wear. Feels a bit narrow so I wear them sparingly.

I bought these to have a dressier, but still-comfortable shoe to wear to work. One of my employers complimented me on them the first day I wore them. Ill be eager to see if they hold up over time. I usually wear a size 13 at J&M, but these are more snug when I put in my arch-support insole. I have relatively narrow feet so I was a little surprised at the snug forefoot fit.

Purchased the Jenson Plain toe in brown with the blue trim sole in store on 01/05/2024. Received it at home a few days later and first impressions it was an awesome shoe. Others have reported that the sole crumbles and less than 90 days later and wearing it less than 10 times the front sole under the toe cap on the left shoe has started to crumble. For a shoe that costs $309.58 with NY state sales tax, this should not happen. Be wary of this type of sole and although the shoe is very stylish and comfortable, you'll be needing a new pair of shoes in no time when it crumbles.

I just wanted to update my one star review! The shoe was returned and exchanged for another style. Thanks to JM for reaching out.

Great pair of shoes.

Very stylish and comfortable

Good quality and comfort

They are great

love the look, comfortable

Just what I expected. Nice quality and comfortable.

Love the fit, comfort, and look. High quality!

Top notch

I bought 3 pairs thinking the next pair would fit, but none did . I purchased the Jenson longwing and it fit great. These two shoes fit totally different. If the Jenson plain too needs to be wider and higher in toe box

This will be second pair of the same shoe. I have never ordered a second pair of the same shoes in my life, and Im 54. I wear these nearly every work day and have them very comfortable and have received many compliments on them. The only real wear has been a smoothening of the sole over time.

My favorite pair of J&Ms

I just wanted to update my one star review! The shoe was returned and exchanged for another style. Thanks to J&M for reaching out.

This is a beautiful shoe BUT super uncomfortable and the heel is awful! My husband wore these one time, for an hour, to the airport. Both of his heels on his ankles were bleeding. The back digs in so hard. I reached out to company , via the website a few times , and no no one ever responded. Super disappointed