Customer Reviews Cole Haan Hawthorne Penny Loafer

Ended up sending these back as they were too narrow for my feet.

The insole is very comfortable and the leather is soft yet holds it's form. It is a nice loafer that I can wear for business or casual dress. (with or without socks)

size is good but leather quality is very cheap and fine

Ultimately I returned this because I preferred the style of some other shoes, but the insoles of this shoe were comparable to shoes much higher in price. Overall construction was good. Fit was spot on. This shoe is a bargain if you like the style. I recommend it despite returning it.

This was a well fitting shoe, but neither myself or my wife liked the style once we actually saw it. It has a pointy toe section that extends significantly beyond your toes. It's a more formal look than some other penny loafers. Construction was solid.

This was a well fitting shoe, but neither myself or my wife liked the style once we actually saw it. It has a pointy toe section that extends significantly beyond your toes. It's a more formal look than many of the other penny loafers that I tried on. It's a good option for a dress shoe. It seemed well made. Its fit was to size. Four out of five for me simply on styling, otherwise 5 stars.

I bought these to replace an almost identical Cole Haan loafers. I have owned several pairs of Cole Haans and I always wear a size 13 D. This shoe fit at least a half size large on me. It was long and wide and I had a lot of heel lift. The quality is good for the price point but this is not the same shoe as most upper end Cole Haans. The liner is lower quality and it is generally a lighter shoe.