Customer Reviews Free People Mystic Mary Jane Flat

Great style, buttery soft leather but seemed to run small—both short and snug toe box. Will be returning for next size up and fingers crossed!

These are great. Not only are they stylish, but the leather is soft and supple. No rubbing on my feet or ankles and I like to walk a lot! The reviews here don't do the shoe justice. I am going to buy another pair in a different color.

Absolutely beautifully crafted leather, such a high end gorgeous shoe. Unfortunately they are too narrow for me. I have a high arch, I thought I could suffer for beauty but I could barely even fasten the loosest hole on the strap. So sad to return these.

I really like these shoes for summer wear. But they do run large. They are great for wide feet but you don’t have to size up. I just wish returns with Zappos were easier. So I kept them and placed an insert.

These came in plastic bag without a box and had been worn. I thought I was ordering new shoes. Crazy!

Beautiful shoes but not for narrow feet. I ordered my normal size 6 and they were at least one size too big. Unfortunately, I could not exchange them because they don't offer a smaller size, so I had to return.

Love these! Super cute, and very comfortable.

Cute design but very lightweight sole and shoes squeek while walking

Very cute shoes but the box of the shoe was too narrow for my left foot. Wish I could have worn them.

I wanted to love them, but they are way too wide, especially in the heel. Sadly I just sent them back.

The style is awesome, the fit is great, and true to size. Going to order the other color to decide which one I like best.

The shoe was tru to size. It’s a cute shoe but there was no arch support.

Oddly shaped shoe - not sure I've seen a foot that could fit in these. Quite wide in the center, narrow in the toe box, and zero support. They look amazing, so it's a bummer that the fit is so bizarre. Returned.