Customer Reviews SoftWalk Tillman

You’d better have a very big fat foot because the upper criss-cross straps are tooooo big & the shoe will never stay on your foot. Man they are so cute & I wanted & needed them to work soooo badly but! Umm, a big no. I’m a pretty standard 12 medium, with little to moderate arch & the sole was good size.

Runs WIDE, toes ended up hanging over because my not narrow foot slid through.

Rough strap but killer deal was the size 12 N was larger width than 11M by a lot!

The fit was fine, but was very abrasive on the top of the foot.

The style, I have always liked. I have noticed the quality is not there anymore. What I mean is the padding of the sandal is almost none. I have a heal spur and could wear these same exact sandals but not anymore. I don't know what has gone wrong. I don't know if Softwalk pays another company to make them now and that is why there is hardly any padding in the heal. I have an old pair of the exact sandal and it has more padding on the heal then the new pair that I received from Softwalk last week. So sad and I really need new sandals!

Very uncomfortable. Straps were very rough and tight.

They were too large and a little rough at the instep.

have them in bronze and black. very comfortable and i have a bunion which is pretty well hidden in this shoe.

I ordered a wide and they sent me a medium width! I have to return now. Too narrow.

I really wanted to love these shoes as I love the style and look. After wearing on second day I started to get bad blister on top of my big toe. Had to stop wearing on third day as top of my toe was so blistered and think I actually had an allergic reaction to whatever material is used. Wish I could return these but I have worn them for 2 days before I noticed this problem. I originally ordered the wide and had to send that back as the straps were way to big and foot fell out. Ordered the regular width and then this happened.

my usual size, but fell off my feet

Love the style, fit and look of these shoes. Bought them as a present for my sister. She designated them as her indoor slip ons. She has grandchildren and doesn't like to have outside shoes worn inside. So, she's had these shoes for a couple of weeks and worn them inside only. She says the finish is coming off the shoes. I want to replace them, but don't want to buy a defective product. Does anyone have any information on whether these shoes have problems with the finish coming off? They are currently being returned.

There was plastic stitching that rubbed on the foot and was uncomfortable. I bought a second pair to try and it had the same problem.

These shoes were a surprising disappointment - fit my narrow foot and the leather is soft and lined with something soft but tore up the tops of my feet, had to send back and shop for a similar style from another company. So sad!

they probably work for other people but they did not stay on my foot. they kept sliding off and I tripped many times. I tripped so much they got really scuffed up so I couldn't even give them away.

I don't know why Softwalk has changed their shoes. They used to fit my narrow foot perfectly. Now most of the narrows are too wide. This one practically fell off my foot.

I ordered these in 9 regular width, they were tight and uncomfortable. Then I ordered them in 9 W, they were loose and uncomfortable. I wondering now, based on the many reviews exclaiming the shoes comfortability (is that a word?), whether I have freaky feet ... hmmmmmmm. Needless to say, both sizes sent back thanks to Zapposs generous return policy. In closing, I’d like to wish a pox on the house of Merril for changing their former magnificently comfortable sandals which I had been wearing for years to designs that are woefully inferior in both comfort and style. Fools! Why screw with perfection!

Love the shoes but they are HUGE - at least a size bigger and wider than they should be. My feet slide to the front and right out. I detest returning anything - what a pain.

inside edge of strap hits right at instep and the strap is rough and sticks out and would cause a blister to form

Color is awful. It’s a full on full, tan color. Photo makes it look a tad more orange. Returning.

Too wide and a very stiff platform.

I wear WW shoe but this was way too wide and no Velcro strap to tighten-also does not have eggcrate design insole- so comfortable- like their Bozeman sandal which is now discontinued

This is a very uncomfortable shoe with no arch support.